Aha! The Consortium! We did not know that Tuck was pushing the envelope over there! We already had a blog post queued up on The Consortium for tomorrow (to follow one we started today on diversity) - this will have to go in it. Thanks, cr1985, for the heads-up, this was one application factoid we'd not known about this season.
On your assumption that adcom folks are baby boomers... uh... not quite! They're Gen Xers, mostly (with some exceptions yes but pretty sure the Tuckies are younger than that!). Check 'em out for yourself:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cqchNG71 ... tube_gdata
https://www.blogger.com/profile/18215669068944883410
https://www.blogger.com/profile/10272599598712226833
(these are just a few - Tuck Admissions is much more open than many other schools' - you should explore more for yourself!)
One thing you can count on is that most adcom are women.
No matter what, though - while the Stones or Beatles may be fine - is that the music that
YOU like??? Sure, everyone likes the Stones/Beatles -- but this video should be reflecting YOU... not what you think the adcom wants to see.
Just our $0.02!!
Anyway, very glad you posted this question - loving it that Tuck is embracing a new medium for their apps this year, even in a limited dose! And it sounds like you're gonna come up with something fun. We've had clients do video essays before and they really do help communicate in such a more personal way!
Good luck with it, and if we can help, let us know!
EssaySnark