What we see: a meaning-in-context question. The passage defines "the unions' dilemma" in its own words, so we find that definition and match it.
Step 1. Find where the passage spells out the choice.
What we see: "Unions faced a choice between either maintaining the prewar status quo or promoting a more inclusive approach that sought for all members the right to participate in the internal affairs of unions, access to skilled and high-paying positions within the occupational hierarchy, and protection against management's arbitrary authority."
What it means: the dilemma is this exact choice. One side is "keep things as they were." The other side is "give every member three things: a voice inside the union, a shot at the good jobs, and protection from the boss."
What we do and why: we sum it up as "should the union give full rights and benefits to all its members, or keep favoring some?" A dilemma is always a choice, so the answer must name the choice the passage names.
Step 2. Check who the choice is about.
What we see: the inclusive approach is for "all members." The African American workers here are already in the unions; the problem is that "in practice unions far more often favored entrenched interests," meaning White members kept the better spots.
What it means: the question is not who gets into the union. It is how members already inside are treated.
What we do and why: this rules out any choice about letting people join.
Step 3. Test each choice.
(A) creating more high-paying jobs is about management, and the dilemma is about who inside the union gets access to the jobs that exist. Out.
(B) taking part in management decisions is not mentioned. The passage says members' role in the union's own affairs. Out.
(C) including minority workers in membership is about joining. They are already members. Out.
(D) extend full rights and benefits to all members. This is the inclusive approach, set against the status quo. Keep.
(E) recruiting new members is never discussed. Out.
The trap: (C). The passage is about race, so "include minority workers" sounds right. But the passage says "all members," so the workers are already inside the union; the fight is over equal treatment, not entry.
Faster way: read the one sentence that starts "Unions faced a choice between." The second half of that sentence is a list of rights for "all members," which is (D) almost word for word.
Takeaway: when a question quotes a phrase from the passage, the passage almost always defines it nearby. Find that sentence and match it before you think about the choices.
Answer: D