In addition to the labor and materials used to make wine, the reputation of the vineyard where the grapes originate plays a role in determining the price of the finished wine. Therefore, an expensive wine is not always a good wine.
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
A) The price of a bottle of wine should be a reflection of the wine's quality.
B) Price is never an accurate indication of the quality of a bottle of wine.
C) The reputation of a vineyard does not always indicate the quality of its wines.
D) The reputation of a vineyard generally plays a greater role than the quality of its grapes in determining its wines' prices.
E) Wines produced by lesser-known vineyards generally are priced to reflect accurately the wines' quality.
IMO: B
Which one of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
A) The price of a bottle of wine should be a reflection of the wine's quality.
B) Price is never an accurate indication of the quality of a bottle of wine.
C) The reputation of a vineyard does not always indicate the quality of its wines.
D) The reputation of a vineyard generally plays a greater role than the quality of its grapes in determining its wines' prices.
E) Wines produced by lesser-known vineyards generally are priced to reflect accurately the wines' quality.
IMO: B
