pls explain y incorrect ans are incorrect
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Live GMAT classes with Target Test Prep start Nov 21 and Nov 22. First class free.
See classesLearn live with an expert or move at your own pace. Every option includes the complete TTP study system.
Target Test Prep was voted #1 Best Test Prep in the 2026 Newsweek Readers’ Choice™ Awards.
with Josh Braslow, 20+ years in test prep
Self-paced EA prep. Study on your schedule.
with
Complete access from day one. Study on your schedule.
My question:rsadana1 wrote:The sentence uses a proper noun - Andre Agassi and is set in very specific context of a sport. Thus, the author of the sentence has a specific Andre Agassi in mind (if we assume that there are multiple Andre Agassi) and does not need to use the clause "who is agile..." to help the reader identify Andre Agassi.
The reasoning above will not hold true if 'player' replaced Andre Agassi. In this case the author will need the help of the clause ' who is agile...' to help the reader identify the player in the context.
Hope this helps.
Sentence 1 : Titanic, the largest ship in violent seas, crashed into the iceberg.rsadana1 wrote:I will try to address this concern. Lets consider two sentences. The version 1 is written in the same form as the original sentence in Question 1 above. And version 2 is written in the same form as the correct answer.
Example 1 - Version 1 = Eiffel Tower, the tallest monument in Paris, was built in 19th century.
Example 1 - Version 2 = Eiffel Tower, which is the tallest monument in Paris, was built in 19th century.
Per the intended meaning of the sentence Eiffel tower is the tallest monument in Paris.
Example 2 - Version 1 = UK, world superpower in 1800s, had a kingdom so large that the sun never set on the British empire.
Example 2 - Version 2 = UK, which was the world superpower in 1800s, had a kingdom so large that the sun never set on the British empire.
Per the intended meaning of the sentence UK was the world super power in 1800s.
Question 1 = Giving a vociferous ... enthusiasm, Goran Ivanisevic served his way ... agile and athletic Andre Agassi.
Here agile and athletic provides a characteristic of Andre Agassi. The sentence states a fact about Agassi stating that he IS agile and athletic.
The above shows that there could be different verb tenses in a sentence such that the intended meaning is communicated effectively.
precisely ! That's it ! There you are ! That's my point!rsadana1 wrote:First of all, I really admire the constructive discussion. Thanks for coming up with this example:
In my opinion both sentences convey the same meaning. If this is the only information provided, then this sentence is grammatically correct.
However, if the sentence provided more information stating whether the ship is destroyed or not, then the which modifier tense will need to be changed accordingly to match the context of the sentence:
Titanic, which is the largest ship in violent seas, crashed into the iceberg but is still functional.
Titanic, which was the largest ship in violent seas, crashed into the iceberg and got completely destroyed.
The bottom-line is the understanding the meaning of the sentence.