Live GMAT classes with Target Test Prep start Nov 21 and Nov 22. First class free.

See classes
Target Test Prep · GMAT

Choose how you want to prepare

Learn live with an expert or move at your own pace. Every option includes the complete TTP study system.

Newsweek Readers’ Choice Awards 2026 winner: Target Test Prep, #1 Test Prep

Target Test Prep was voted #1 Best Test Prep in the 2026 Newsweek Readers’ Choice™ Awards.

★★★★★5.0563 reviews
GMATLiveTeachStarts Nov 22
Josh Braslow, Target Test Prep GMAT expert
LIVE ONLINE CLASSES

Get Ready for GMAT Test Day Faster with Live Online Classes

with Josh Braslow, 20+ years in test prep

Nov 22 · Josh Braslow
Sun · 9:30 AM to 12:30 PM ET
Included
40 hours of live online classes + 6 months of TTP OnDemand
  • Attend the first class for free
  • Every class is recorded, so you never fall behind
View classes & enroll
Limited seats availableTarget Test Prep
EALiveTeachOnDemandStart anytime
EXECUTIVE ASSESSMENT

Target Test Prep EA OnDemand

Self-paced EA prep. Study on your schedule.

EXECUTIVE ASSESSMENT

with

165+ EA score guarantee
$05-day trial no automatic billing
Schedule
Included
40 hours of live online classes plus six months of access to the complete TTP EA OnDemand course.
  • 165+ EA Score Guarantee
  • 4,100+ Quant, Verbal, and Integrated Reasoning practice questions
  • 400+ hours of in-depth video lessons
  • 3,000+ step-by-step video solutions
View EA class & enroll Start free 5-day trial
Limited cohort · enrollment openTrial includes full course accessTarget Test Prep
GMATOnDemandStart anytime
SELF-PACED MASTERCLASS

Target Test Prep GMAT OnDemand

Complete access from day one. Study on your schedule.

715+ score guarantee
$0to start then $127/mo
  • Personalized study plan and analytics
  • Thousands of lessons and practice questions

Please Rate: Analysis of Argument

Expert replies
by mandarchougule » Tue Nov 29, 2011 8:03 am
The following appeared in a memo to the President of Baby-And-Me Bread Company:
"Late last year we switched the supplier we use for bread bags in our Windy City bakery plant to AAA Plastics. This year we have seen over 5000 defects in bags and each defective bag causes a need to throw out the loaf of a bread. In our Bentonville bakery plant, where we use ZZZ Plastics, there have only been 1000 defects in our bread bags. Even though AAA plastics charge considerably less for their bread bags, we should switch our WIndy City Plant to ZZZ Plastics in order to save money. "


The President of Baby-And-Me bread company is concerned about the quality of the bags used in the bread factory at Windy City. As per author, the president, the quality of the bags used in Windy City Factory is poorer compared those used in the Bentonville Factory, because last year 5000 defects related to bags were observed at Windy City Factory, whereas only 1000 defects were observed at Bentonville Factory. The author further says that although cost of the bag used in Windy City factory, procured from AAA Plastics is less than cost of bag used in Bentonville factory, which is supplied by ZZZ Plastics, switching the bags at Windy City from AAA Plastics to ZZZ Plastics will yield savings. The argument by author is very weak due to many reasons and the reasons behind it have been mentioned below.
First of all, the author claims that the cost of bag from AAA Plastics is lower than the cost of bag from ZZZ Plastics. Author further claims that changing the bag used in Windy City Factory will lead to cost savings. It is difficult understand how using costly packing material will lead to savings. Maybe author would like to bring into consideration the cost savings brought by reduced wastage of bread as a result of reduced defects in bags. Nevertheless author needs to present the relevant cost benefit analysis in order to strengthen the argument.
Another major flaw in the argument is regarding the measurement of the defects in the bag. The author mentions that there were 5000 defects in the bags used at Windy City Factory against 1000 defects in bags used at Bentonville Factory. However author does not mention the total production at each of the factories. It might have been the case that the production at Windy City was more than 5 times that of in Bentonville. In such case, the bags used in Windy City prove to be superior than bags used in the Bentonville. In order to bring further clarity in this regard, author needs to use proper unit of measurement for measuring defects such as no. of defects per 1000 breads produced. Moreover the argument solely relies on the data of last year. The validity of argument can be brought into question by bringing in the past data about defects at Bentonville.
Further to add the author assumes that the machinery used in the Windy City is performing at the same efficiency as the one in Bentonville. It could be the case that the machinery in the Windy City factory is responsible for higher defects while the plastics bags used are of the good quality. Thus in order to substantiate his claim author needs to present the root cause analysis behind the higher number of defects at the Windy City factory.
Thus the argument has several weaknesses. In order to make the argument stronger, author needs to present the measurement of defects in proper units that will make the defects at both of the factories comparable. Also author needs to present the cost benefit analysis to prove that strategy of using bags from ZZZ Plastics will yield savings. Finally root cause analysis is essential to identify the reason behind higher number of damages at Windy City factory.
Join the discussion
Source: — GMAT Essays (AWA) |

by chieftang » Tue Nov 29, 2011 5:45 pm
mandarchougule wrote:The following appeared in a memo to the President of Baby-And-Me Bread Company:
"Late last year we switched the supplier we use for bread bags in our Windy City bakery plant to AAA Plastics. This year we have seen over 5000 defects in bags and each defective bag causes a need to throw out the loaf of a bread. In our Bentonville bakery plant, where we use ZZZ Plastics, there have only been 1000 defects in our bread bags. Even though AAA plastics charge considerably less for their bread bags, we should switch our WIndy City Plant to ZZZ Plastics in order to save money. "


The President of Baby-And-Me bread company is concerned about the quality of the bags used in the bread factory at Windy City. As per author, the president, the quality of the bags used in Windy City Factory is poorer compared those used in the Bentonville Factory, because last year 5000 defects related to bags were observed at Windy City Factory, whereas only 1000 defects were observed at Bentonville Factory. The author further says that although cost of the bag used in Windy City factory, procured from AAA Plastics is less than cost of bag used in Bentonville factory, which is supplied by ZZZ Plastics, switching the bags at Windy City from AAA Plastics to ZZZ Plastics will yield savings. The argument by author is very weak due to many reasons and the reasons behind it have been mentioned below.
First of all, the author claims that the cost of bag from AAA Plastics is lower than the cost of bag from ZZZ Plastics. Author further claims that changing the bag used in Windy City Factory will lead to cost savings. It is difficult understand how using costly packing material will lead to savings. Maybe author would like to bring into consideration the cost savings brought by reduced wastage of bread as a result of reduced defects in bags. Nevertheless author needs to present the relevant cost benefit analysis in order to strengthen the argument.
Another major flaw in the argument is regarding the measurement of the defects in the bag. The author mentions that there were 5000 defects in the bags used at Windy City Factory against 1000 defects in bags used at Bentonville Factory. However author does not mention the total production at each of the factories. It might have been the case that the production at Windy City was more than 5 times that of in Bentonville. In such case, the bags used in Windy City prove to be superior than bags used in the Bentonville. In order to bring further clarity in this regard, author needs to use proper unit of measurement for measuring defects such as no. of defects per 1000 breads produced. Moreover the argument solely relies on the data of last year. The validity of argument can be brought into question by bringing in the past data about defects at Bentonville.
Further to add the author assumes that the machinery used in the Windy City is performing at the same efficiency as the one in Bentonville. It could be the case that the machinery in the Windy City factory is responsible for higher defects while the plastics bags used are of the good quality. Thus in order to substantiate his claim author needs to present the root cause analysis behind the higher number of defects at the Windy City factory.
Thus the argument has several weaknesses. In order to make the argument stronger, author needs to present the measurement of defects in proper units that will make the defects at both of the factories comparable. Also author needs to present the cost benefit analysis to prove that strategy of using bags from ZZZ Plastics will yield savings. Finally root cause analysis is essential to identify the reason behind higher number of damages at Windy City factory.
Friendly pieces of advise:

1. Avoid using "it" without reference. You've done this repeatedly... "It is difficult", "It could be the case", etc.

2. Avoid saying you don't understand something. "It is difficult understand how using costly packing material will lead to savings." Your difficulty in understanding something doesn't bolster your argument; it undermines your argument.

3. Use "First," instead of "First of all,".

I like your point about root cause analysis. In general, pointing out alternate explanations/possibilities seems like a sound strategy. And ceratainly, in this case, if there is a flaw in the Windy City plant's bagging procedure or apparatus, then the higher failure rate may not be related to the bags themselves at all!
Join the discussion