-
vaibhav.iit2002
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 295
- Joined: Tue Jul 15, 2008 10:07 am
- Thanked: 4 times
- GMAT Score:690
An oil field prospector and developer reported a large oil deposit in southwestern Texas. As a result, a large oil and gas company purchased the field with the intention of drilling oil wells in the area soon afterwards. However, the company found that what had been reported to be a large oil deposit was actually much smaller than had been indicated. Thus, the methods that the prospector had used to determine the size of the oil deposit must have been inaccurate.
Which of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
a. The company's methods of measuring the size of the oil deposit were determined by a third party to be more accurate than those used by the prospector.
b. The prospector did not purposefully fabricate or misrepresent the size of the oil deposit.
c. Though smaller than originally thought, the oil deposit contained enough oil to make drilling commercially feasible.
d. The prospector did not explore other oil fields and use the same methods to determine the magnitude of the oil present, if any.
e. The company had successfully drilled for oil in other large oil fields in Texas throughout the early twentieth century.
My ques. is that if ques. were "Which of the following is an assumption on which the conclusion depends?" , would u have changed your answer/approach?
As ques. asks assumption on which argument depends, should we consider only last line of paragraph [which is conclusion] to find assumption or consider whole para ?
Which of the following is an assumption on which the argument depends?
a. The company's methods of measuring the size of the oil deposit were determined by a third party to be more accurate than those used by the prospector.
b. The prospector did not purposefully fabricate or misrepresent the size of the oil deposit.
c. Though smaller than originally thought, the oil deposit contained enough oil to make drilling commercially feasible.
d. The prospector did not explore other oil fields and use the same methods to determine the magnitude of the oil present, if any.
e. The company had successfully drilled for oil in other large oil fields in Texas throughout the early twentieth century.
My ques. is that if ques. were "Which of the following is an assumption on which the conclusion depends?" , would u have changed your answer/approach?
As ques. asks assumption on which argument depends, should we consider only last line of paragraph [which is conclusion] to find assumption or consider whole para ?
