Kaplan Test

The question states: the claim can serve as argument "against" which view

i.e which conclusion out of the four possible, can be weakened by the given premise

Option B: the argument endorses the view given in B and not oppose it

D seems to be correct

Wats the OA

ayushiiitm wrote:The question states: the claim can serve as argument "against" which view

i.e which conclusion out of the four possible, can be weakened by the given premise

Option B: the argument endorses the view given in B and not oppose it

D seems to be correct

Wats the OA

Doesn't the premise say that the uncommon (rare but extreme cases )case lead to public outrage and not the common standard ones.. Hence doesnt B contradict the premise?Am i missing something ?
However the answer is D

No its not like that

You just think yourself into an argument

Consider someone says: A fraud can be both common and lead to outrage
To counter you will give him an example about how it is not possible. Either it is uncommon or it does not lead to outrage
You dont explain how uncommon can cause an outrage. Factually Uncommon always lead to an outrage

Somebody tells you : public is only interested in standard cases of welfare
To counter you say: No it is not. Havent you seen the example.....and you tell story like given in the premise


Hope I make some sense to you

Can anybody elaborate why A is not the correct option.

What i understand from para is that the argument provided can be used as a support in limiting the welfare spending..hence it can be used against any argument which is opposite

kaulnikhil wrote:

ayushiiitm wrote:The question states: the claim can serve as argument "against" which view

i.e which conclusion out of the four possible, can be weakened by the given premise

Option B: the argument endorses the view given in B and not oppose it

D seems to be correct

Wats the OA

Doesn't the premise say that the uncommon (rare but extreme cases )case lead to public outrage and not the common standard ones.. Hence doesnt B contradict the premise?Am i missing something ?
However the answer is D