John and Mike

Based on first principle Distance = Speed x Time; If we write the eqn for John and Mike separately
Distance (John) = Speed (J) x Time (J) ..... 1
Distance (Mike) = Speed (M) x Time (M) ..... 2

Since the total distance traveled is same i.e Distance (J) = Distance (M)
From eqn 1 and 2 above
Speed (J) x Time (J) = Speed (M) x Time (M)
Time (M) = Speed (J) X Time (J)/Speed (M)

Per statement I Speed(M)/Speed(J) = 3/4
Time (M) = (4/3) * 15 =20min5 * 15/3 = 20min
Statement I is enough.

Based on Statement II we can only arrive at speed of John and no more information is available either on relative time of arrival or relative speed and hence II is not enough.

I would go with option A, statement I alone is enough. BTW, what is OA?

Kanak

but it says AVERAGE speed...which doesnt really tell you anything,

I would say E if its any recollection of the questions I've had where they try to trick you by saying Average speed.

Don't think that all average speed questions are tricky & answer choices that have that wording are wrong. In this case average speed should be good enough information. We are dealing with the entire length for both the people. So, as per the formula:

Avg speed = (Total Distance)/(Total time taken)

Stmt 2 just gives the distance, we don't know anything about their individual speeds, so not good enough.

A is sufficient to answer the question.

so what IS the correct answer???????

kapitalist wrote:so what IS the correct answer???????

If it comes out other than A then dont rely on the source.