I just discovered this thread, and wish I hadn't have posted my question to the general forum now as the discussion here is much more suited to my question. I'll repost what I had below. Thanks Amy for answering all of these questions from everyone, I've read a few pages and will definitely have to make sure I read all of it.
"Overview:
-26 year old white male
-Industrial Engineering undergrad, state school but top-ranked IE program (3.0 GPA in major, <3.0 overall)
-Stayed an extra year to get my MS, joint engineering/business program (3.75 GPA)
-Will have 4 years work experience when I attend B school. 2 years in a leadership development rotational program at a big defense contractor. Quit at the end of the program to join a small engineering consulting firm where I have been working the past year. Experience in operations and finance.
- 750 GMAT (48Q, 47V, 6.0 AW)
- Extracurriculars: Sort-of non-existant (I have a lot of hobbies that take up my time outside of work). Have gotten involved with initiating a Corporate Social Responsibility team at my current company, in which we'll take on pro-bono projects for non-profits.
I'm planning on applying to top 10 schools in the near future. I'm still figuring out what I want to do, but I'll probably end up applying to Harvard, UPenn, MIT, Northwestern, Chicago. The big question on my mind is how big a factor my undergraduate GPA will play. I think the rest of my application could be strong ... did well on the GMAT obviously, and have taken on significant responsibilities in the past year at my current company. I think I can write compelling application essays about how I've evolved in my career. Part of the reason I stayed to get my masters was my bad undergraduate GPA, and I'm planning on writing an essay about turning my GPA around between undergrad and graduate. I've heard that masters GPA doesn't matter too much for admissions because many applicants do not have a masters and there is no basis for comparison. What role does my masters play in my application? Will my GMAT score plus masters GPA balance out my below-average undergraduate GPA?
Thanks!!"