Hi there,
Congrats on both offers! this is a great situation to be in. You have to look at the following factors in order to make a decision:
1. Starting salary after graduation from both schools
2. Top recruiting companies at each school
3. Overall placement data for the school - how many people found jobs and how long it took them
4. Size and power of the network of each school

The best way to make a decision is to talk with students and alumni in each program and see what they say about career services, and their ability to network and leverage their experience. You also have to take the location into consideration - if you'll be in Fordham you will be in the city every day, making life easier in terms of networking.
I think that in the NYC area Fordham might have a better branding, also because of its prestigious law school. You need to figure out if the starting salary post Fordham (and the overall network) will be able to compensate for the higher tuition costs.

Best,
Yael, Admit1MBA
www.admit1mba.com

If you find my post helpful, please let me know by pushing the thank button.

In general I think Fordham has the better reputation. However, I would really focus on which companies recruit from either school and which ones you want to work at afterwards. Since they are regional schools, the strength of the recruiting will be all local companies so make sure their is a match there.