In criminal proceedings, defense attorneys occasionally attempt to establish that a suspect was not present at the commission of a crime by comparing the suspect’s DNA to the DNA of blood or hair samples taken from the scene of the crime. Although every person’s DNA is unique, DNA tests often fail to distinguish among DNA samples taken from distinct individuals. Hence, it is a mistake to exonerate a suspect simply because that person’s DNA did not match the DNA samples taken
from the scene of the crime.
Which one of the following is an error in the reasoning
above?
(A) It assumes without warrant that the use of physical evidence in identifying suspects is never mistaken.
(B) It confuses a test that incorrectly identifies DNA samples as coming from the same person with a test that incorrectly shows as coming from
different persons samples that come from a single person.
(C) It generalizes about the reliability of all methods used to identify those involved in the commission of a crime on the basis of results
that pertain to only a few such methods.
(D) It relies on experimental data derived from DNA testing that have not been shown to hold under nonexperimental conditions.
(E) It fails to demonstrate that physical evidence taken from the scene of a crime is the only sort of evidence that should be admitted in criminal
court proceedings.
[spoiler]OA: B[/spoiler]
from the scene of the crime.
Which one of the following is an error in the reasoning
above?
(A) It assumes without warrant that the use of physical evidence in identifying suspects is never mistaken.
(B) It confuses a test that incorrectly identifies DNA samples as coming from the same person with a test that incorrectly shows as coming from
different persons samples that come from a single person.
(C) It generalizes about the reliability of all methods used to identify those involved in the commission of a crime on the basis of results
that pertain to only a few such methods.
(D) It relies on experimental data derived from DNA testing that have not been shown to hold under nonexperimental conditions.
(E) It fails to demonstrate that physical evidence taken from the scene of a crime is the only sort of evidence that should be admitted in criminal
court proceedings.
[spoiler]OA: B[/spoiler]
Last edited by turbo jet on Wed Jun 17, 2009 11:34 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Life is Tom; I am Jerry 
