FDPs -- Help Evaluating Factorials

Question

Hi All,

I'm a new poster -- but long-time reader -- of the BTG Forum looking for help on this question from a recent MGMAT CAT exam. I know the answer is D once you convert them all to a common denominator of 5(9!), but I'm struggling to understand why.

Could someone please offer up an explanation for why D is the correct choice? Specifically, the MGMAT CAT explanation says you should multiply answer choice D by 8 and 9 to get the common base -- and I don't understand why that 8 gets thrown in.

Thanks for your help!
Laura

Which of the following has the greatest value?
(A) 3/8!
(B) 6(4!)
5(9!)
(C) 4(3!)
9!
(D) 3
5(7!)
(E) 14
5(8!)

akhpad · Answer

Answer choices are not in proper way. Can you please arrange it?

laura003 · Answer

Sorry about that. In the problem, MGMAT doesn't use the fraction bar on choices B, C, D, and E, it just has one number on top of the other w/o the bar in the middle, so I was trying to mimic that. For the purposes of clarity and legibility though, I'll add in the fraction bar on all the answer choices.

Which of the following has the greatest value?
(A) 3/8!
(B) 6(4!)/5(9!)
(C) 4(3!)/9!
(D) 3/5(7!)
(E) 14/5(8!)

Thanks!
Laura

akhpad · Answer

(A) 3/8! = 135 / ( 5 * 9! ) (B) 6(4!)/5(9!) = 144 / ( 5 * 9! ) (C) 4(3!)/9! = 120 / ( 5 * 9! ) (D) 3/5(7!) = 216 / ( 5 * 9! ) (E) 14/5(8!) = 126 / ( 5 * 9! ) Hence D

laura003 · Answer

Thanks for your quick reply. Why did you multiply by 8 on answer choice (D) to get 216/5(9!)?

I understand that you needed to multiply by 9 to get the 5(9!) denominator, but I'm not sure why the 8 was also necessary.

Thank you!

akhpad · Answer

For comparison, it is better to compare in integer rather than fraction. I made 5 * 9! at denominator. All nominator become integer.

Stuart@KaplanGMAT · Answer

laura003 wrote:Sorry about that. In the problem, MGMAT doesn't use the fraction bar on choices B, C, D, and E, it just has one number on top of the other w/o the bar in the middle, so I was trying to mimic that. For the purposes of clarity and legibility though, I'll add in the fraction bar on all the answer choices.

Which of the following has the greatest value?
(A) 3/8!
(B) 6(4!)/5(9!)
(C) 4(3!)/9!
(D) 3/5(7!)
(E) 14/5(8!)

Thanks!
Laura

Hi,

for (D), we're changing 7! to 9!.

Well, 9! = 9*8*7!

So, to get a denominator of 9!, we need to multiply the top and bottom of the fraction by 9*8:

3/5(7!) * (9*8)/(9*8)

= 3*9*8/5*(9*8*7!)

= 216 /5*(9!)

Stuart Kovinsky | Kaplan GMAT Faculty | Toronto

Kaplan Exclusive: The Official Test Day Experience | Ready to Take a Free Practice Test? | Kaplan/Beat the GMAT Member Discount
BTG100 for $100 off a full course

laura003 · Answer

Thank you both!

govind_raj_76 · Answer

Akhilesh

How did u arrive at a common number ? Did u go by taking the max of dr 5(9!) in option B , made that a reference to change other options A,C,D and E ?

(A) 3/8! = 135 / ( 5 * 9! )
(B) 6(4!)/5(9!) = 144 / ( 5 * 9! )
(C) 4(3!)/9! = 120 / ( 5 * 9! )
(D) 3/5(7!) = 216 / ( 5 * 9! )
(E) 14/5(8!) = 126 / ( 5 * 9! )

Thanks,

akhpad · Answer

Yes, we can say max of Denominators in this case.

But in general, if we have to compare fractional numbers, take the LCM of denominators and make the denominator common (LCM) so that we can compare Nominator only.

Usually, we should not play with the factional numbers as this is a time consuming.

Choose how you want to prepare

Get Ready for GMAT Test Day Faster with Live Online Classes

Target Test Prep EA OnDemand

Target Test Prep GMAT OnDemand

FDPs -- Help Evaluating Factorials

Chicago Booth

GMAT Course Reviews

Admissions Consulting Reviews

FREE GMAT PREP RESOURCES

GMAT PREP DEAL TRACKER