Fastest way to solve this speed/time/distance problem?

Question

A left P for Q at 10:00 A.M and at the same time B left Q for P. Both A & B took the same route. They meet at 11:20 A.M. If both of them start from P, B will reach Q 2 hours earlier than A. What is the time taken by A to reach Q?

GMATGuruNY · Answer

Kevinst wrote:A left P for Q at 10:00 A.M and at the same time B left Q for P. Both A & B took the same route. They meet at 11:20 A.M. If both of them start from P, B will reach Q 2 hours earlier than A. What is the time taken by A to reach Q?

The time for A and B to meet = 4/3 hours.
Since B travels faster than A, in this amount of time B has covered more than 1/2 the distance from Q to P.
Thus, it will take B LESS than 4/3 more hours to reach P.
Thus, the time for B to cover the ENTIRE distance from Q to P must be BETWEEN 4/3 hours and 8/3 hours.
It seems VERY likely that B's time = 2 hours, implying that A's time = 4 hours.

Let the distance from P to Q = 8 miles.
Rate for B = d/t = 8/2 = 4 miles per hour.
Rate for A = d/t = 8/4 = 2 miles per hour.
When elements WORK TOGETHER to cover the distance between them, we ADD their rates.
Time for A and B to meet = d/(combined rate) = 8/(4+2) = 4/3 hours.
Success!

Thus, the time for A to travel from P to Q = 4 hours.

natali · Answer

GMATGuruNY wrote:Kevinst wrote:A left P for Q at 10:00 A.M and at the same time B left Q for P. Both A & B took the same route. They meet at 11:20 A.M. If both of them start from P, B will reach Q 2 hours earlier than A. What is the time taken by A to reach Q? The time for A and B to meet = 4/3 hours. Since B travels faster than A, in this amount of time B has covered more than 1/2 the distance from Q to P. Thus, it will take B LESS than 4/3 more hours to reach P. Thus, the time for B to cover the ENTIRE distance from Q to P must be BETWEEN 4/3 hours and 8/3 hours. It seems VERY likely that B's time = 2 hours, implying that A's time = 4 hours. Let the distance from P to Q = 8 miles. Rate for B = d/t = 8/2 = 4 miles per hour. Rate for A = d/t = 8/4 = 2 miles per hour. When elements WORK TOGETHER to cover the distance between them, we ADD their rates. Time for A and B to meet = d/(combined rate) = 8/(4+2) = 4/3 hours. Success! Thus, the time for A to travel from P to Q = 4 hours.[/quote mitch, i still dont understand much.can you please just use tradiional way to solve this problem?

cypherskull · Answer

Am not sure if I'd go on to solve this on actual GMAT. I'd rather take a guess and move than solve this problem the way I did. Here's my solution:

Time taken for A and B to meet = 4/3 hrs
Let s1 and s2 represent the speeds of A & B and t1 & t2 represent the times taken.

Therefore,

4/3 (s1 + s2) = d

or,
4(s1+s2) = 3d ------ (1)

Second part of the problem states that both starting P, B took 2 hrs less.

So,

d/s1 - d/s2 = 2

or

d = 2s1*s2/(s2-s1) ------- (2)

Putting (2) in (1), we'd get -

2(s2/s1) - 2(s1/s2) = 3

Solving the above equation, we get - s2 = 2s1.

Now since s2 = 2s1, surely t2 = t1/2 for the same distance.

Its given that time taken by B was 2 hrs less than the time taken by A.

So,

t1 - t2 = 2

or, t1 - t1/2 = 2 => t1 = 4 Answer.

Regards,
Sunit

________________________________

Kill all my demons..And my angels might die too!

GMATGuruNY · Answer

natali wrote:GMATGuruNY wrote:Kevinst wrote:A left P for Q at 10:00 A.M and at the same time B left Q for P. Both A & B took the same route. They meet at 11:20 A.M. If both of them start from P, B will reach Q 2 hours earlier than A. What is the time taken by A to reach Q? The time for A and B to meet = 4/3 hours. Since B travels faster than A, in this amount of time B has covered more than 1/2 the distance from Q to P. Thus, it will take B LESS than 4/3 more hours to reach P. Thus, the time for B to cover the ENTIRE distance from Q to P must be BETWEEN 4/3 hours and 8/3 hours. It seems VERY likely that B's time = 2 hours, implying that A's time = 4 hours. Let the distance from P to Q = 8 miles. Rate for B = d/t = 8/2 = 4 miles per hour. Rate for A = d/t = 8/4 = 2 miles per hour. When elements WORK TOGETHER to cover the distance between them, we ADD their rates. Time for A and B to meet = d/(combined rate) = 8/(4+2) = 4/3 hours. Success! Thus, the time for A to travel from P to Q = 4 hours.[/quote mitch, i still dont understand much.can you please just use tradiional way to solve this problem? When elements work together, ADD THEIR RATES. A's rate + B's rate = their combined rate. Since A and B leave at 10am and meet at 11:20am, they take 4/3 hours to cover the distance between them. To make the algebra easier, we can think of the distance between them as ONE JOB, letting d=1. Thus, their combined rate = d/t = 1/(4/3) = 3/4. Let A's time = a. Then A's rate = 1/a. Since B's time is 2 hours less than A's time, B's time = a-2. B's rate = 1/(a-2). Since A's rate + B's rate = their combined rate, we get: 1/a + 1/(a-2) = 3/4 (a-2 + a)/(a²-2a) = 3/4 8a - 8 = 3a² - 6a 3a² -14a + 8 = 0 (3a - 2)(a - 4) = 0 a = 2/3 or a = 4. a = 2/3 implies that B's time is negative -- not viable. Thus, A's time = 4 hours.

cypherskull · Answer

Thanks Mitch! That seems like a much easier approach!

Kevinst · Answer

Nice approach, Mitch!

To avoid confusion it should be noted:

"Thus, their combined rate = d/t = 1/(4/3) = 3/4."
Mitch divides 1 by (4/3) because the calculated rate shows the "number of distances" that can be traveled in a certain time, not how many miles or km.

This basically transforms the problem in a "Machines-Rate-problem":

Machines A and B work at different constant rates.
A and B together get one job done in 80 Minutes.
If A and B work separately, B finishes one job 2 hours earlier than A.
How long does it take A to finish one job on his own?

Looking at the problem from this perspective makes it a lot more feasible for me.

Choose how you want to prepare

Get Ready for GMAT Test Day Faster with Live Online Classes

Target Test Prep EA OnDemand

Target Test Prep GMAT OnDemand

Fastest way to solve this speed/time/distance problem?

Chicago Booth

GMAT Course Reviews

Admissions Consulting Reviews

FREE GMAT PREP RESOURCES

GMAT PREP DEAL TRACKER