BREAKING: Target Test Prep releases Brand New 2026 On Demand GMAT prep course

Redeem

Elders.. tough one...

Expert replies
by nervesofsteel » Wed Jul 29, 2009 11:14 pm
24. An unbiased observer of everyday encounters in Western societies would surely not find many instances of unkindness by people under 65 toward people over 65. There are undoubtedly incidents of unkindness based on age, and these warrant reproof. However, the very fact that such reproof occurs and is generally accepted implies that our Western societies basically respect the elderly. The same conclusion can be drawn from a recent survey finding: 71 percent of the under 65 population agreed with the statement that “people over 65 receive too little respect from society”, while only 44 percent of the over-65 population, the target of the alleged irreverence agreed with it.
The author concludes that Western societies basically respect the elderly partly because
(A) people under 65 are just as kind to people over 65 as they are to people of their own age group
(B) survey data suggest that fewer people over 65 than under 65 get too little respect
(C) disrespect for the elderly does not go so far as to result in actual harm
(D) survey data suggest that people over 65 are more aware of incidents involving disrespect to the elderly than are people under 65
(E) incidents of unkindness to the elderly are neither common nor generally accepted in Western societies


OA E

Please explain the reasoning...
Join the discussion
Source: — Critical Reasoning |

by viju9162 » Thu Jul 30, 2009 1:50 am
tough to crack ...I thought C to be the answer
"Native of" is used for a individual while "Native to" is used for a large group
Join the discussion

Re: Elders.. tough one...

by vyomb » Thu Jul 30, 2009 3:21 am
nervesofsteel wrote:24. An unbiased observer of everyday encounters in Western societies would surely not find many instances of unkindness by people under 65 toward people over 65. There are undoubtedly incidents of unkindness based on age, and these warrant reproof. However, the very fact that such reproof occurs and is generally accepted implies that our Western societies basically respect the elderly. The same conclusion can be drawn from a recent survey finding: 71 percent of the under 65 population agreed with the statement that “people over 65 receive too little respect from society”, while only 44 percent of the over-65 population, the target of the alleged irreverence agreed with it.
The author concludes that Western societies basically respect the elderly partly because
(A) people under 65 are just as kind to people over 65 as they are to people of their own age group--no mention as such data neither in the premise nor in conlcusion-eliminate
(B) survey data suggest that fewer people over 65 than under 65 get too little respect-nothing as such mentiond in the conclusion-eliminate
(C) disrespect for the elderly does not go so far as to result in actual harm--there is no mention of any harm only unkindness is mentioned-eliminate
(D) survey data suggest that people over 65 are more aware of incidents involving disrespect to the elderly than are people under 65--no such statistical dat present in the premise or conlcusion to prove this-eliminate
(E) incidents of unkindness to the elderly are neither common nor generally accepted in Western societies--incidents of unkindness warrant reproof why?? because they are not generally accepted


OA E

Please explain the reasoning...
Join the discussion

by ogbeni » Thu Jul 30, 2009 1:52 pm
Answer is E

Interesting question. This is more like a RC question because it is asking for what premise(s) the conclusion rests upon. So just go straight to the stimulus.

"There are undoubtedly incidents of unkindness based on age, and these warrant reproof (proof that in incidents of unkindness are not common - earlier sentence reads "would surely not find many instances of unkindness by people under 65 toward people over 65"). However, the very fact that such reproof occurs and is generally accepted (proof that in incidents of unkindness to the elderly are not accepted)implies that our Western societies basically respect the elderly."
Join the discussion

by gmat740 » Thu Jul 30, 2009 5:29 pm
What is the source of the question?
Join the discussion

by nervesofsteel » Thu Jul 30, 2009 9:03 pm
the source is 1000 CR
Join the discussion

by joseph32 » Sun May 15, 2016 8:51 pm
Guys can anyone give a decent reason why E is not right.
Join the discussion