goelmohit2002 wrote:mittalashwani13 wrote:goelmohit2002 wrote:nikhilgirdhar wrote:
Not only X but Y I is idiomatically incorrect on GMAT
the correct idioms are:
Not X but Y
Not only X but also Y
XY parallelism hast to be maintained.
IMO
Not only X but [also] Y.
is correct idiom that is liked by GMAT....
Please see the Q#216 and Q#241 of OG-10.....
In the explanations of these questions....OG mentions that not only X but [also] Y is the correct idiom...
also is optional here.....but it is preferable to have...as per OG.
Mohit - Could you please provide me ONE Official problem where OA is with the construction "Not only X but [also] Y ?
As far as I know the OA were all having not only...but also both...
But the explantion of Q#216 and Q#241 in OG says that the options that were not having "also" are kicked out not because of "also" not present....but because of other errors that GMAT do not like...
So what I interpret from OG is that not only...but [also] is correct idiom....
Kaplan also say that "also" is optional.
Please correct me if my understanding is wrong.
OG says only in the explanation of #241 that not only ...but also is preferable over not only ...but [also] ....but i never saw a single problem where i can found not only ...but [also] is deemed correct...
But ...It is a matter of caution ...because on the Standard English,
Not only ...but [also] is correct ...also you can use synonym for "also" such as "as well" , "too" etc...
Not Only ...[but] also is also correct ...
And and and...
Not only ... is also correct in some of the cases ...
BUT AS FAR AS GMAT is Concerned ....GMAT never tested the incomplete idiom. GMAT always tested Not only ...but also construction...
Last edited by
mittalashwani13 on Fri Jul 03, 2009 11:44 am, edited 1 time in total.