Easiest SC question....But I have a question

reply2spg
Please do not discourage me and many more like me by saying that this is the easiest question ........it really shakes confidence of the beginners.

Well it has shaken my confidence as well, I chose B over A but still do not understand why a is right and b is wrong.The only difference below is bring and brings and the relative pronoun that refers to life style which is singular so the verb should be singular as well brings... can some one explain where I am going wrong?

(A) the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that bring warmth

(B) the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that brings warmth

Same here.. i chose B over A

folkways and a life-style should be plural... so bring should be used....

Any Experts to comment ?

nervesofsteel wrote:Same here.. i chose B over A

folkways and a life-style should be plural... so bring should be used....

Any Experts to comment ?

@nervesofSteel...

U are correct.
folkways and a life-style should be plural... so bring should be used....Agreed!!

Well to explain AO-A according to me,

You should always see the Verb and find out what it is referring to in Very tricky questions the Verb may be referring to a singular noun in that case you would need a "Brings" rather than "Bring",

So lets try and do it for this Bring refers to "have evolved folkways and a life-style that" Hence it has to be Plural.

And there not one but 100's I know who scored 410 and went onto score 700+, The exam is about patterns. noting else sooner you realize easier it gets.

I think now this question is becoming harder. But believe me this is comparatively easy question.

Still I didn't get answer to my question. What 'that' refers to? As per relative pronoun rule 'that' or 'which' should refer to the immediate preceding noun. If that is the case then B should be correct over A. However, I think here 'that' refers to both 'evolved folkways and a life-style', but I don't understand how to find out the same?

Experts Fibbo, Ron, Stacy, Machoman, Testluv somebody please help me out to get out with this confusion.

Virtually undisturbed for the last three centuries on their starkly beautiful islands near the edge of the Arctic Circle, the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that bring warmth to their harsh environment.

(A) the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that bring warmth
(B) the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that brings warmth
(C) evolving folkways and a life-style were evolved by the Lofotens inhabitants to bring warmth
(D) evolving folkways and a life-style brought warmth to the Lofotens’ inhabitants as well as
(E) warmth-bringing folkways and life-styles have been evolved by the inhabitants of the Lofotens

Some Grammar:

1. I love X and Y that are my favorite dishes.

"X and Y" has been used as a single unit, but the that refers to the whole of "X and Y". So, after that the verb should be plural.
=> This eliminates B.
2. The openinig modifier "virtually undisturbed" should modify the noun of the next clause, and it is surely the inhabitants.
=> It eliminates C, D, and E.

Answer: A

Thanks Perfect....I will call you expert going forward.

gmat_perfect wrote:Virtually undisturbed for the last three centuries on their starkly beautiful islands near the edge of the Arctic Circle, the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that bring warmth to their harsh environment.

(A) the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that bring warmth
(B) the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that brings warmth
(C) evolving folkways and a life-style were evolved by the Lofotens inhabitants to bring warmth
(D) evolving folkways and a life-style brought warmth to the Lofotens’ inhabitants as well as
(E) warmth-bringing folkways and life-styles have been evolved by the inhabitants of the Lofotens

Some Grammar:

1. I love X and Y that are my favorite dishes.

"X and Y" has been used as a single unit, but the that refers to the whole of "X and Y". So, after that the verb should be plural.
=> This eliminates B.
2. The openinig modifier "virtually undisturbed" should modify the noun of the next clause, and it is surely the inhabitants.
=> It eliminates C, D, and E.

Answer: A

Virtually undisturbed for the last three centuries on their starkly beautiful islands near the edge of the Arctic Circle, the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that bring warmth to their harsh environment.

(A) the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that bring warmth
(B) the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that brings warmth

I think A but wanted to be sure about my logic, Please someone correct me if I am wrong.

If the sentence means the "a life style that brings warmth" "a life-style that bring warmth" part would precede the "folkways" and the better sentence would be:
"the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolked a life style that brings warmth and folkways"

Therefore we can assume subject is 'folkways and a life style" and verb should be plural...

I just wanted to sure if this approach is correct and can work in other similar questions. Thanks in advance...

reply2spg wrote:I know that this is the easiest question. However, I got it wrong this time. Can somebody please help me to understand what 'that' refers to? Source 1000 SC Q # 914

Virtually undisturbed for the last three centuries on their starkly beautiful islands near the edge of the Arctic Circle, the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that bring warmth to their harsh environment.

(A) the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that bring warmth
(B) the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that brings warmth
(C) evolving folkways and a life-style were evolved by the Lofotens inhabitants to bring warmth
(D) evolving folkways and a life-style brought warmth to the Lofotens’ inhabitants as well as
(E) warmth-bringing folkways and life-styles have been evolved by the inhabitants of the Lofotens

OA A

When a sentence begins with a modifying phrase, ask yourself who or what the phrase is modifying:

Who or what is virtually undisturbed? The inhabitants. So the noun inhabitants must come after the introductory phrase. Eliminate C, D, and E.

Whenever you see a verb, ask yourself who or what is performing the action of the verb:

Who or what is bringing warmth to the environment? The folkways and the lifestyle. Since this is a plural subject, the verb bring has to be plural: the folkways and the lifestyle bring warmth. Eliminate B because in B the verb brings is singular.

The correct answer is A.

GMATGuruNY wrote:

reply2spg wrote:I know that this is the easiest question. However, I got it wrong this time. Can somebody please help me to understand what 'that' refers to? Source 1000 SC Q # 914

Virtually undisturbed for the last three centuries on their starkly beautiful islands near the edge of the Arctic Circle, the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that bring warmth to their harsh environment.

(A) the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that bring warmth
(B) the inhabitants of the Lofotens have evolved folkways and a life-style that brings warmth
(C) evolving folkways and a life-style were evolved by the Lofotens inhabitants to bring warmth
(D) evolving folkways and a life-style brought warmth to the Lofotens’ inhabitants as well as
(E) warmth-bringing folkways and life-styles have been evolved by the inhabitants of the Lofotens

OA A

When a sentence begins with a modifying phrase, ask yourself who or what the phrase is modifying:

Who or what is virtually undisturbed? The inhabitants. So the noun inhabitants must come after the introductory phrase. Eliminate C, D, and E.

Whenever you see a verb, ask yourself who or what is performing the action of the verb:

Who or what is bringing warmth to the environment? The folkways and the lifestyle. Since this is a plural subject, the verb bring has to be plural: the folkways and the lifestyle bring warmth. Eliminate B because in B the verb brings is singular.

The correct answer is A.

Hi Mitch, Thanks for your clarification. What if i were to assume that only 'lifestyle brings warmth to their environment' ? In that case i will have to use a 'singular verb' after 'that'. What is your take on this question? Do we see such ambuiguity in real GMAT ?

Looking forward to your comments!