E , why not D?

Question

In parts of South America, vitamin-A deficiency is a serious health problem, especially among children. In one region, agriculturists hope to improve nutrition by encouraging farmers to plant a new variety of sweet potato called SPK004 that is rich in betacarotene, which the body converts into vitamin A. The plan has good chances of success, since sweet potato is a staple of the region's diet and agriculture, and the varieties currently grown contain little beta-carotene. Which of the following, if true, most strongly supports the prediction that the plan will succeed?
A. There are other vegetables currently grown in the region that contain more beta-carotene than the currently cultivated varieties of sweet potato do.
B. The flesh of SPK004 differs from that of the currently cultivated sweet potatoes in colors and textures, so traditional foods would look somewhat different when prepared from SPK004.
C. For successful cultivation of SPK004, a soil significantly richer in nitrogen is needed than is needed for the varieties of sweet potato currently cultivated in the region.
D. There are no other varieties of sweet potato that are significantly richer in beta-carotene than SPK004 is.
E. The currently cultivated varieties of sweet potato contain no important nutrients that SPK004 lacks.

OA is E, but why not D? Could some one explain this?

macattack · Answer

Problem: Vitamin A deficiency is a serious health problem.
Solution: Plant SPK004 rich in beta-carotene. (Beta-carotene is transformed into vitamine A once digested)
Assumption made: The SPK004 does not lack any important nutrients that the current variety of sweet potatoes has.

In the above passage we are analyzing whether the new variety of sweet potatoes is a viable substitute for the already cultivated ones. We are not arguing that it is the best solution.

D. There are no other varieties of sweet potato that are significantly richer in beta-carotene than SPK004 is. (Irrelevant, even if there was other varieties of sweet potatoes richer in beta-carotene the SPK004 would still be a viable substitute to the currently cultivated ones. (It is richer, not the richest)

E. The currently cultivated varieties of sweet potato contain no important nutrients that SPK004 lacks. This addresses addresses the assumption made above, strengthening the argument.

P.S. In most CR questions, an assumption is made. In this case the assumption was implicit, you might not have caught it when reading the passage.

I hope this helped!

Rich.C@EMPOWERgmat.com · Answer

Hi race2mba,

Here is some additional insight regarding questions that involve a "plan." For a plan to work, it must solve the existing problem AND not create any new problems.

In this prompt, the plan is to replace one type of sweet potato (that doesn't have enough Vitamin A) with another sweet potato (which does have enough Vitamin A). We would have to assume that the newer sweet potato solves the existing problem AND doesn't create any new ones. To support the idea that the plan will work, we need to find an answer that says that this is the case.

Answer D doesn't give us the assurance that we need. Answer E does.

GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made,
Rich

Contact Rich at [email protected]

Choose how you want to prepare

Get Ready for GMAT Test Day Faster with Live Online Classes

Target Test Prep EA OnDemand

Target Test Prep GMAT OnDemand

E , why not D?

GMAT/MBA Expert

Chicago Booth

GMAT Course Reviews

Admissions Consulting Reviews

FREE GMAT PREP RESOURCES

GMAT PREP DEAL TRACKER