QUESTION:When it rains,my car gets wet.Since it hasn,t rained recently,my car cant be wet.

Which of the following is logically most similar to the argument above.

(A) Whenever critics give a play a favorable review,people go to see it,pinters new play did not receive favorable reviews,so i doubt that anyone will go to see it.

(B) Whenever people go to see a play,critics give it a favorable review,people did go to see pinters new play,so it did get a favorable review.

(c)Whenever critics give a play a favorable review,people go to see it,pinters new play got favorable reviews,so people will probably go to see it.

(D)Whenever a play is given favorable reviews by the critics,people go to see it,since people are going to see pinters new play,it will probably get favorable reviews.

(E)Whenever critics give a play a favorable review,people go to see it,people are not going to see pinters new play,so it did not get favorable reviews.

I saw this question in ARCO S GMAT.According to them the anwser is A.but in my opinion the answer must be C.Please correct me if i m wrong.Thanks.