Builder

Question

A master builder is building a new house. He gets 3 apprentices who EACH work 2/3 as fast as he does. If all 4 work on it together, they should finish it in what fraction of the time that it would have taken the master builder working alone?

a)4/7
b)1/3
c)2/3
d)3/4
e)4/3

[spoiler]OA: B[/spoiler]

bubbliiiiiiii · Answer

let the rate of work of master be x.

rate of work of each apprentice is 2x/3.

rate of work of 3 apprentices is 2x/3 * 3= 2x.

Combined rate of all four is 3x.

Let the piece of work be n.

then,

if master at rate x can do the work in n units then the team at rate 3x can do in n/3.

Thus, B

Please let me know if the approach is correct or not.

Regards,

Pranay

pemdas · Answer

i also think it's b

the rate of three workers is 2x/3 and the rate of builder is x
(2x/3)*3 + x = work, given One work, work=1 ==> (2x/3)*3+x=1, x=1/3
the speed of builder is 1/3 work per time unit and the combined speed of three workers is (1/3)*(2/3)*3 or 2/3 work per time unit. Builder and three workers have combined speed of 1 work per time unit.

So if all 4 work they do one work in 1 time unit. If builder does one work alone, he spends 3 time units. The relationship is 1/3.

GmatKiss wrote:A master builder is building a new house. He gets 3 apprentices who EACH work 2/3 as fast as he does. If all 4 work on it together, they should finish it in what fraction of the time that it would have taken the master builder working alone?

a)4/7
b)1/3
c)2/3
d)3/4
e)4/3

GMATGuruNY · Answer

GmatKiss wrote:A master builder is building a new house. He gets 3 apprentices who EACH work 2/3 as fast as he does. If all 4 work on it together, they should finish it in what fraction of the time that it would have taken the master builder working alone?

a)4/7
b)1/3
c)2/3
d)3/4
e)4/3

Let work = 18 units.
Let rate for master builder = 3 units per hour.
Then rate for each apprentice = (2/3)*3 = 2 units per hour.
Combined rate for master builder and 3 apprentices = 3 + (3*2) = 9 units per hour.
Time for all workers = w/r = 18/9 = 2 hours.
Time for master builder alone = w/r = 18/3 = 6 hours.
Time for all workers/Time for master builder alone = 2/6 = 1/3.

The correct answer is B.

bubbliiiiiiii · Answer

Thanks mitch for acknowledging the answer and providing us with a plug-in approach.

A question here:

Why/How can we reach the answer by using the work done per day concept to reach the answer. I tried to do that and got 11/3 as my answer.

Regards,

Pranay

GMATGuruNY · Answer

bubbliiiiiiii wrote:Thanks mitch for acknowledging the answer and providing us with a plug-in approach.

A question here:

Why/How can we reach the answer by using the work done per day concept to reach the answer. I tried to do that and got 11/3 as my answer.

Let x = master builder rate.
Time for master builder = 1/x.

Rate for each apprentice = (2/3)x.
Rate for 3 apprentices = 3*(2/3)x = 2x.
Combined rate for master builder and 3 apprentices = x + 2x = 3x.
Time for all workers = 1/(3x).

Time for all workers/Time for master builder alone = [1/(3x)] / (1/x) = 1/(3x) * x = 1/3.

bubbliiiiiiii · Answer

Thanks again for response.

I was approaching it this way.

Let x = master builder rate.
Time for master builder = 1/x.

Rate for each apprentice = (2/3)x.
Time for each apprentice = 1/[(2/3)x] = 3/(2x)

Time for all workers = 1/x+3*[3/(2x)] {Time for master = 3 * Time for each apprentice}

1/x + 9/2x = 11/(2x).

What is wrong with bold faced statements. When do we use that approach?

Regards,

Pranay

GMATGuruNY · Answer

bubbliiiiiiii wrote: Time for each apprentice = 1/[(2/3)x] = 3/(2x)

Time for all workers = 1/x+3*[3/(2x)] {Time for master = 3 * Time for each apprentice}

Times can't be added in this manner. When elements work together, more work is produced in less time, so the amount of time needed is reduced.

If it takes John 2 days to produce 4 widgets and Mike 3 days to produce 4 widgets, it will NOT take John and Mike 2+3 = 5 days to produce 4 widgets: since John and Mike will be working together, the time will be reduced considerably.

Choose how you want to prepare

Get Ready for GMAT Test Day Faster with Live Online Classes

Target Test Prep EA OnDemand

Target Test Prep GMAT OnDemand

Builder

Chicago Booth

GMAT Course Reviews

Admissions Consulting Reviews

FREE GMAT PREP RESOURCES

GMAT PREP DEAL TRACKER