Profile Evaluation Request– Need help on re-applying or no

Launched September 22, 2008
This topic has expert replies
Junior | Next Rank: 30 Posts
Posts: 13
Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2011 9:52 pm
Thanked: 1 times
Hi,

I was applying to four schools for Fall 2012, Johnson, Kelley, Kenan-Flagler, Marshall. I am being dinged for Kelley and Kenan-Flagler so far while Johnson placed me on waitlist without the interview and nothing from Marshall yet.

All of them were applied in R2 and now I am panic whether I should prepare for re-apply next year.
My latest GMAT score was 640 (Q47, V 30, AWA 5.5) and that was the third time I took it. The previous GMAT was 620 (Q49, V25, AWA 4.5).

Working experience is: 2 years as a licensed banker with one of the largest retail bank in the US, 1 year as a stock broker with a mid-size local firm. Also, a comprehensive accounting contract experience for 1 year in San Francisco. Total years of experience are 4 years. In addition, received a promotion to become a registered client associate within the investment department back in Nov, majority assisting financial advisors on analysis report generation and client inquiry, not sure if this would help.

Academic: I was graduated from University of Arizona in the US as finance major in 2007, not an ivy school with a major GPA of 3.23/4.00.

Activities post-graduate: Being volunteer with different projects organized by the company, e.g., adopt-a-family, helping Salvation Army assist foster children, homeless family,etc.

Background: Chinese American, was born and raised in Hong Kong. Planning to re-take CFA level 1 in December this year. Short-term goal post-graduate plans to work in I-Bank as securities analyst for emerging market in the East Coast. Long-term goal plans to become entrepreneur for an advisory/consulting firm in HK. (Very typical and common goal)

I have updated with Johnson (Cornell) that additional recommendation will be provided no later than the first week of April and an updated resume will be sent with my promotion. Plan to re-take the GMAT, but no really ready to exceed 640 yet.

My question is:
1. Should I re-take the GMAT anyways?
2. Should I withdraw my rest of applications for this year? (seems like Johnson and Marshall are harder to get in compare to Kelley and KF)
3. If I do re-apply next year for the same schools, would they favor in re-applicants?
4. Should I consider consulting advice for schools? (Those are very EXPENSIVE)
5. If re-applying, what other programs should I consider?
Source: — Ask Clear Admit |

User avatar
MBA Admissions Consultant
Posts: 82
Joined: Mon Feb 06, 2012 1:44 pm
Thanked: 13 times
Followed by:31 members

by Deena@ClearAdmit » Wed Mar 28, 2012 7:06 am
Hi JeffAU524 and thanks for your post!


Hi,

I was applying to four schools for Fall 2012, Johnson, Kelley, Kenan-Flagler, Marshall. I am being dinged for Kelley and Kenan-Flagler so far while Johnson placed me on waitlist without the interview and nothing from Marshall yet.

All of them were applied in R2 and now I am panic whether I should prepare for re-apply next year.
My latest GMAT score was 640 (Q47, V 30, AWA 5.5) and that was the third time I took it. The previous GMAT was 620 (Q49, V25, AWA 4.5).

Working experience is: 2 years as a licensed banker with one of the largest retail bank in the US, 1 year as a stock broker with a mid-size local firm. Also, a comprehensive accounting contract experience for 1 year in San Francisco. Total years of experience are 4 years. In addition, received a promotion to become a registered client associate within the investment department back in Nov, majority assisting financial advisors on analysis report generation and client inquiry, not sure if this would help.

Academic: I was graduated from University of Arizona in the US as finance major in 2007, not an ivy school with a major GPA of 3.23/4.00.

Activities post-graduate: Being volunteer with different projects organized by the company, e.g., adopt-a-family, helping Salvation Army assist foster children, homeless family,etc.

Background: Chinese American, was born and raised in Hong Kong. Planning to re-take CFA level 1 in December this year. Short-term goal post-graduate plans to work in I-Bank as securities analyst for emerging market in the East Coast. Long-term goal plans to become entrepreneur for an advisory/consulting firm in HK. (Very typical and common goal)

I have updated with Johnson (Cornell) that additional recommendation will be provided no later than the first week of April and an updated resume will be sent with my promotion. Plan to re-take the GMAT, but no really ready to exceed 640 yet.

My question is:
1. Should I re-take the GMAT anyways?

I would not advise retaking the GMAT unless you have a sense that your score will increase. Another score of 640, or a lower score will not help your profile. I would suggest though, that you retake the GMAT if you can put in some study time and improve your score.

2. Should I withdraw my rest of applications for this year? (seems like Johnson and Marshall are harder to get in compare to Kelley and KF)

I don't see a benefit to withdrawing your applications. At the very least, you can see what Johnson's and Marshall's decisions are on your application, before you make any decisions about what to do next.
3. If I do re-apply next year for the same schools, would they favor in re-applicants?

The schools that you are considering are quite neutral when it comes to reviewing reapplicant files. Often, however, programs will want to see how your profile has improved or changed since your last application. You will want to think about ways in which you have developed more leadership, have an improved GMAT score, additional extra-curricular involvement, etc. if the schools you are reapplying to ask you for updates since your last application.
4. Should I consider consulting advice for schools? (Those are very EXPENSIVE)

Clear Admit offers a free initial assessment of your profile. Feel free to contact us at [email protected] to set up a time to speak with someone who can give you some honest feedback about your profile!
5. If re-applying, what other programs should I consider?


You might want to look at GW University, University of Denver, Wake Forest University.

Feel free to contact us at [email protected] for a free initial assessment!

Best,

Deena

Deena Maerowitz
Clear Admit, LLC

Stay Informed with Clear Admit!
Read our Blog for daily MBA admissions tips and updates.
Follow us on Twitter for breaking b-school news.
Download our Publications on MBA programs and admissions strategy.
Visit our MBA Admissions Wiki to read and share application insights.
Friend us on Facebook for exclusive giveaways and Q&A with our team.
Deena Maerowitz
MBA Admissions Expert
Clear Admit

Junior | Next Rank: 30 Posts
Posts: 13
Joined: Thu Aug 25, 2011 9:52 pm
Thanked: 1 times

by jeffau524 » Wed Mar 28, 2012 11:30 am
Thank you Deena, I will take serious consideration on your advice.