Is the Answer [spoiler]{E}[/spoiler]?

theCodeToGMAT wrote:Is the Answer [spoiler]{E}[/spoiler]?

[spoiler]My answer is D.[/spoiler]

Well, I thoroughly enjoyed this problem, although it seems more like a Challenge Problem of the Week than a question that you'd actually see on the GMAT.

Here's my attempted explanation in two slides:

Matt@VeritasPrep wrote:Well, I thoroughly enjoyed this problem, although it seems more like a Challenge Problem of the Week than a question that you'd actually see on the GMAT.

Here's my attempted explanation in two slides:

It will feel like a Challenge Problem of the Week if one tries to finish the calculation part, which is never necessary on DS. If we can foresee where a statement can take us to, we are done.

The key catch of the problem lies in the stem itself, and that is that P must lie on the longer side of the rectangle ABCD, or the rectangle ABCD cannot be a square and BC is the longer side; and this should not take us too long by trying sophisticated algebra to realize that P is along the longer side, simple imagination is sufficient.

Those who fail to draw it right would fail to make the decision right. Further, we can note that the three right triangles ABP, APD, and PCD so formed are all similar, and also recall that triangles on the same base and under the same parallel lines are same in area. Hence, the area of triangle PBD is same as the area of triangle ABP which is ½ AP.AB.

One side and ratio can determine everything about three similar right triangles, therefore [spoiler]each statement alone is sufficient[/spoiler], hence [spoiler]D[/spoiler] is the right choice. We don't need to be on pins and needles really.