BREAKING: Target Test Prep releases Brand New 2026 On Demand GMAT prep course

Redeem

Operator puzzle

Expert replies
by ronsom » Fri Apr 16, 2010 7:53 pm
Image

One more question from GMATPrep. The triangle symbolized one of the four mathematical operators..
I wonder how statement (1) alone would be sufficient to answer the question..
(1) 3 TRIANGLE 2 > 3
This can be the case with X and + both the operators as 3+2 > 3 as well as 3x2 > 3
(2) 3 TRIANGLE 1 = 3
This can be the case with divisor and multiplier both, as, 3/1 = 3 and 3x1 = 3 as well.

But from (1) and (2), it can be confirmed that the TRIANGLE is actually a multiplier (x).

However, GMATPrep marks (1) as sufficient enough! (option A of DS)
Join the discussion
Source: — Problem Solving |

by liferocks » Fri Apr 16, 2010 8:45 pm
for ease of edit i will refer the mentioned operator as 'O'
to satisfy the relation
(6 O 2) O 4=6 O (2 O 4) 'O' has to be either addition or multiplication

now from statement 1 we get
3 O 2>3--this is possible only when 'O' is either addition or mutiplication.hence sufficient

from statement 2
3 O 1=3..this is possible when '0' is either multiplication or division--insuff

Ans is A
Join the discussion

by pops » Fri Apr 16, 2010 8:50 pm
(6@2)@4=6@(2@4)
this would be true if,
(A) @ is either + or X (since minus and division wont solve the equation)

statement1: 3@2>3
3+2=5>3 true
3 X 2=6>3 true
3-2=1>3 false
3/2=1.5>3 false

hence @ is either + or X. hence sufficient for (A)


statement2: 3@1=3
this means @ can be X or division..
hence we cant answer (A)

hence A
Join the discussion

by ronsom » Fri Apr 16, 2010 8:55 pm
But the question asks "If the operation TRIANGLE is one of the four arithmetic operations".
From Statement (1) we can select either multiplication or addition, but only Statement (2) in combination with statement (1) would further narrow down to the answer "multiplication". The question says, TRIANGLE is one of the four operators..
Join the discussion

by liferocks » Fri Apr 16, 2010 8:58 pm
ronsom wrote:But the question asks "If the operation TRIANGLE is one of the four arithmetic operations".
From Statement (1) we can select either multiplication or addition, but only Statement (2) in combination with statement (1) would further narrow down to the answer "multiplication". The question says, TRIANGLE is one of the four operators..
it is correct that only combining both we can definitely say the nature of the operator but the question is not 'what is the operator' it is 'using the operator does the given equation hold true'

statement 1 is sufficient to say that the given relation is true we don't need the second statement for it.
Hope it clarifies why it should be A instead of C.
Join the discussion

by thephoenix » Fri Apr 16, 2010 9:09 pm
ronsom wrote:But the question asks "If the operation TRIANGLE is one of the four arithmetic operations".
From Statement (1) we can select either multiplication or addition, but only Statement (2) in combination with statement (1) would further narrow down to the answer "multiplication". The question says, TRIANGLE is one of the four operators..
the question never asked about the symbol,
it is asking whether (6@2)@4=6@(2@4)???????
s1) is therfore sufficient as with bth multiplication and addition we get an answer
Join the discussion

by Testluv » Sun Apr 18, 2010 8:03 pm
ronsom wrote:But the question asks "If the operation TRIANGLE is one of the four arithmetic operations".
From Statement (1) we can select either multiplication or addition, but only Statement (2) in combination with statement (1) would further narrow down to the answer "multiplication". The question says, TRIANGLE is one of the four operators..
Especially in yes/no data sufficiency questions, you should always simplify or rephrase the stem.

The question clause asks whether the left hand side (LHS) of the equation equals the right hand side (RHS). We know that the triange is one of the four listed operations. For which of these four operations will the LHS equal the RHS?

Well, since the order in which you add or multiply is not important, the LHS will equal the RHS if the triangle represents either of addition or multiplication.

As you point out, the inequality in (1) is satisfied only if the triangle represents either of addition or multiplication. Thus, regardless of whether it is addition or multiplication the LHS of the equation in the question will definitely equal the RHS. (It matters not that addition and multiplication would lead to different values).

As an aside, please post DS questions in the DS forum (you've posted this one in the PS forum).
Kaplan Teacher in Toronto
Join the discussion

by akhpad » Sun Apr 18, 2010 8:40 pm
I also agree; A is the answer
Join the discussion