No one but him could have told them that the thief was I
A. him could have told them that the thief was I
B. he could have told them that the thief was I
C. he could have told them that the thief was me
D. him could have told them that the thief was me
E. he could have told them the thief was me
OA A
Even after loads of discussions experts cant conclude OA
https://www.manhattangmat.com/forums/sc- ... t5294.html
https://gmatclub.com/forum/no-one-but-hi ... 0a6496bb8f
Experts any thoughts ??
5-Day Free Trial
5-day free, full-access trial TTP
Available with Beat the GMAT members only code
MORE DETAILS
him could have told them that the thief was I
This topic has expert replies
-
vipulgoyal
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 468
- Joined: Mon Jul 25, 2011 10:20 pm
- Thanked: 29 times
- Followed by:4 members
GMAT/MBA Expert
-
ceilidh.erickson
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 2095
- Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2012 3:22 pm
- Thanked: 1443 times
- Followed by:247 members
This is not a GMAT-like problem. What is the source? The GMAT will never use the first person ("I" or "me") in a SC question.
Before I dive into technicalities, a disclaimer: you don't need any of the following for the GMAT!
The verb "to be" takes a predicate (a subject compliment), not an object. So the correct use is "it is I" rather than "it is me." We use the subject pronoun "i," not the object pronoun "me." Therefore, in the given sentence, the only correct construction is "the thief was I."
This rule is a shibboleth of English teachers and grammar snobs, and does not reflect the way that English is actually spoken - even by a majority of well-educated English speakers. The GMAT will not test this sort of rule.
As for "he" v. "him," the "but" is a preposition and should thus take the object pronoun, much like "with him," "for him," "aside from him," etc.
So, A is the correct answer. The larger takeaway here, though, is that this is not a question that will help you in any way to prepare for the GMAT. Please let us know the source of this question, so students can avoid it!
(PLEASE ALWAYS POST YOUR SOURCES!)
Before I dive into technicalities, a disclaimer: you don't need any of the following for the GMAT!
The verb "to be" takes a predicate (a subject compliment), not an object. So the correct use is "it is I" rather than "it is me." We use the subject pronoun "i," not the object pronoun "me." Therefore, in the given sentence, the only correct construction is "the thief was I."
This rule is a shibboleth of English teachers and grammar snobs, and does not reflect the way that English is actually spoken - even by a majority of well-educated English speakers. The GMAT will not test this sort of rule.
As for "he" v. "him," the "but" is a preposition and should thus take the object pronoun, much like "with him," "for him," "aside from him," etc.
So, A is the correct answer. The larger takeaway here, though, is that this is not a question that will help you in any way to prepare for the GMAT. Please let us know the source of this question, so students can avoid it!
(PLEASE ALWAYS POST YOUR SOURCES!)
Ceilidh Erickson
EdM in Mind, Brain, and Education
Harvard Graduate School of Education
EdM in Mind, Brain, and Education
Harvard Graduate School of Education
-
Aman verma
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 304
- Joined: Wed Jan 27, 2010 8:35 am
- Location: International Space Station
- Thanked: 11 times
- Followed by:3 members
vipulgoyal wrote:No one but him could have told them that the thief was I
A. him could have told them that the thief was I
B. he could have told them that the thief was I
C. he could have told them that the thief was me
D. him could have told them that the thief was me
E. he could have told them the thief was me
OA A
Hello Vipulgoyal,
First of all I am not an expert; just trying to make an humble effort as a student to help and understand in the process !
Now, the construction of the sentence is inverted or expletive.So if you rearrange the sentence in the normal order you can see the structure clearly ."that the thief was I " rearrange this portion in the normal order "I was the thief", it cannot possibly be " me was the thief " . So you can clearly see why the Nominative case is used. You can also read back the sentence in this normal order "No one but him could have told them that I was the thief". You cannot possibly use 'me' in place of 'I'. Regarding, 'him' in "No one but him" it will always be in the Accusitive case since 'no one' is in the Nominative case.
800. Arjun's-Bird-Eye
