What is the verb?

This topic has expert replies
Senior | Next Rank: 100 Posts
Posts: 30
Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2013 5:28 am
GMAT Score:21 V

What is the verb?

by bhakk » Sun Aug 04, 2013 9:38 am
Source: E-GMAT.
The proliferation of personal computing by laptops and desktops had started in 1998 with the advent of internet and is continuing since then so much so that over 90% of Americans now own at least one personal computing device.
A) had started in 1998 with the advent of internet and is continuing since
B) had been started in 1998 with the advent of internet and has been continuing since
C) started in 1998 with the advent of internet that has been continuing since
D) has started in 1998 with the advent of internet and has been continuing since
E) started in 1998 with the advent of internet and has been continuing since

OA - E

My analysis:
I thought 'started' is a past particle (-ed form) and needs a helping verb so chose the wrong answer- (D).
But after reading the answer, I came to know that 'started' is a verb-ed modifier.
Now I have 2 doubts:
1) In the clause: "The proliferation of personal computing by laptops and desktops started in 1998 with the advent of internet and has been continuing since then so much so"
What is the verb in the above clause?
2) is it possible for 'has been continuing' (verb) to refer to 'proliferation' (Subject) when the sentence has 'AND' in between?

TIA.
Source: — Sentence Correction |

Legendary Member
Posts: 544
Joined: Mon Dec 27, 2010 8:10 am
Thanked: 45 times
Followed by:2 members

by sameerballani » Sun Aug 04, 2013 11:30 am
bhakk wrote:Source: E-GMAT.
The proliferation of personal computing by laptops and desktops had started in 1998 with the advent of internet and is continuing since then so much so that over 90% of Americans now own at least one personal computing device.
A) had started in 1998 with the advent of internet and is continuing since
B) had been started in 1998 with the advent of internet and has been continuing since
C) started in 1998 with the advent of internet that has been continuing since
D) has started in 1998 with the advent of internet and has been continuing since
E) started in 1998 with the advent of internet and has been continuing since

OA - E

My analysis:
I thought 'started' is a past particle (-ed form) and needs a helping verb so chose the wrong answer- (D).
But after reading the answer, I came to know that 'started' is a verb-ed modifier.
Now I have 2 doubts:
1) In the clause: "The proliferation of personal computing by laptops and desktops started in 1998 with the advent of internet and has been continuing since then so much so"
What is the verb in the above clause?
"The proliferation of personal computing by laptops and desktops started in 1998 with the advent of internet and has been continuing since then so much so"

Ignore the yellow part while reading.
The verbs in the above sentence are: START and CONTINUE(in the base form)
What tense they take depends on the sequence they occur.
bhakk wrote: 2) is it possible for 'has been continuing' (verb) to refer to 'proliferation' (Subject) when the sentence has 'AND' in between?

TIA.
"The proliferation of personal computing by laptops and desktops started in 1998 with the advent of internet and has been continuing since then so much so"

Whenever confused about the subject of a verb -> Ask yourself, Who/What did the verb?
In this case, What has been continuing?
The answer is: PROLIFERATION of.....

Eg: The EXAM founded by Tom & Jane had started in the year 1947 and stopped in the year 1950.

Hope this helps !!
If my post was helpful, then please click "Thank".

• Page 1 of 1