from one :-
x>0>y
from 1 we can conclude that x is positive and y is negative
so we have the orginal equation in the form:-
X(+ ve)
--------------------------------
X(+ve) + Y(as Y negative)
<
-Y -X
---------------------------
2(1 -y)
so y-x
---------
2(1+y)
will result in a positive fraction only when y <-1 hence ..otherwise it wil
result in a negative value hence less than L.H.S
Hence NOT SUFFICIENT
from 2.
y<-1
if X is negative we get X/x-y greater and if xis positive we get y-x/2(1+y)
NOT sufficient
combine both noe u know X is possitive and Y <-1
so RHS will be greater
Hope I make sense
-------