Plugging numbers - inequalities contain 2 variables

This topic has expert replies
Source: — Data Sufficiency |

User avatar
Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
Posts: 135
Joined: Tue Mar 22, 2011 12:01 pm
Thanked: 21 times
Followed by:3 members
GMAT Score:720

by sourabh33 » Sat Jul 02, 2011 11:04 pm
Statement 1 : M-3Z>0

Case 1
Let M = 5 and Z = -6
M-3Z -> 5-3(-6) = 23 >0
M+Z -> 5-6 = -1 <0

Case 2
Let M = 5 and Z = -3
M-3Z -> 5-3(-3) = 14 >0
M+Z -> 5-3 = 2 >0

Since both > and < are possible, statement 1 is insufficient


Statement 2 : 4Z-M>0

Case 1
Let M = -5 and Z = 2
4Z-M -> 4x2 -(-5) = 13 >0
M+Z -> -5+2 = -3 <0

Case 2
Let M = -5 and Z = 6
4Z-M -> 6x2 -(-5) = 17 >0
M+Z -> -5+6 = 1>0

Since both > and < are possible, statement 2 is insufficient


Taking Statement 1&2 together

If we were to plug numbers here, we would have to come up with numbers that could fulfill both the equations 1 & 2. In all such cases we would find that M & Z are positive and therefore M+Z will be >0

Examples
M = 5, Z = 1.5
M = 10, Z = 3
M = 15, Z = 4
M = 15, Z = 4.5

Therefore Statement 1 & 2 together are sufficient.

A better way to solve this would be simplifying equation and deriving the properties

From 1 -> M>3Z
From 2 -> 4Z>M

Therefore 4Z>3Z; now this can only be possible when z is positive
In addition when z is positive M has to be positive (using statement 1 M>3Z)

Therefor 1&2 together are sufficient

C