Gange72 wrote:One of the most maddening things I just came across, in Critical Reasoning - weakening, is that the answer is sometimes the one that has almost no bearing on the topic. I literally had to select the answer that didn't 'strengthen' the argument and by default 'weakened' the argument. Any suggestions on how to deal with this?
That depiction of weakening questions is not really accurate. The right Critical Reasoning weakening answer definitely has a bearing on the topic and clearly weakens the argument.
As I said above, scoring high in verbal takes vision, or noticing key details and seeing what is going on, and use of logic to determine which answer is correct. If you don't really see what is going on, yes, the correct answer to a weakening question may appear to have basically nothing to do with the argument in the prompt. The truth is, however, that that appearance is illusory. So essentially what you are doing in choosing answers just because they don't strengthen the arguments is, rather than actually connecting the dots, taking a shortcut, one that will not lead to your scoring very high in the Critical Reasoning aspect of verbal. The only way to rock CR is to actually see the connections and the logic of what is going on.
While the wording of Critical Reasoning questions can be convoluted, the questions are not as whacked as you have made them out to be. Once you develop more skill in seeing what is going on in Critical Reasoning questions, the logic of them will become abundantly clear, and you won't be doing things like choosing answers just because they by default don't strengthen the arguments.
You are best off working on CR practice questions slowly and taking the time to learn to see what is actually going on. Just the other day, as I was working with someone, we noted that fully addressing each CR question that we worked on during the session took around 20 minutes.
While I can see how sentence correction could be considered a cornerstone of scoring high in verbal, in a sense, Critical Reasoning is the cornerstone of the entire test, as every part of the test is testing your skill in seeing what is going on and reasoning your way to the correct answer.