BREAKING: Target Test Prep releases Brand New 2026 On Demand GMAT prep course

Redeem

Osteoporosis is a disease characterized

Expert replies
by patanjali.purpose » Sun Jan 29, 2012 2:20 pm
Osteoporosis is a disease characterized by a deterioration of bone tissue which causes an interference in bone microarchitecture and a subsequent susceptibility to fractures. The causes of the disease are obscure and the medications used in its treatment can only slow bone loss without rebuilding bone tissue. In women, osteoporosis often occurs after a sharp drop in estrogen production, but women are also diagnosed with this disease before the onset of menopause. Although osteoporosis is often associated with elderly women, it is also common among people with certain hormonal disorders or users of glucocorticoids. Fractures are most common in the vertebral column, the pelvis and the carpals, although they are possible in any bone in the body.

Recently, a new theory has emerged which offers an explanation of bone formation and of the bone loss associated with osteoporosis. According to this theory, osteoporosis can be linked to a mutation of gene LRP5. Gene LRP5 controls serotonin production in the gut, a completely separate mechanism from the serotonin produced in the brain. The more serotonin the gut produces, the more inhibited the growth of bone cells.

Important yet inconclusive experimental support for this theory comes from laboratory experiments with mice. Scientists deactivated the LRP5 gene in the DNA of mice, which caused the bone-forming cells to degenerate. However, the same cells were then examined in the laboratory where, without any exposure to serotonin, they developed normally. Unfortunately, human patients suffering from osteoporosis did not have an abnormal amount of serotonin in their blood.

The second paragraph performs which of the following functions in the passage?
A) It resolves a problem presented in the first paragraph.
B) It presents a theory which is negated in the third paragraph.
C) It connects a problem raised in the first paragraph with a solution offered in the third paragraph.
D) It offers a theory which is explained further in the third paragraph.
E) It presents a possible solution for a problem presented in the first paragraph.

Pls explain your pick.

Why the author uses the term 'unfortunately' in the last sentence of the passage?
Join the discussion
Source: — Reading Comprehension |

by sai.99.gmat » Sun Jan 29, 2012 4:03 pm
Option (B)?

I might be wrong, but from what I see,

Second Paragraph -> explains about a new theory (excess of serotonin causing osteoporosis), support comes from experiment with Mice...but the osteoporosis human patients never showed any excess of serotonin...

Expertss....correct me?
Join the discussion

by avik.ch » Sun Jan 29, 2012 8:02 pm
1st para : Osteoporosis - defination, how it is caused ?

2nd para : Theory for the explanation of bone formation and of the bone loss associated with osteoporosis - description

3rd para : experimental support of this theory - mice experiment.

Only D stands out.

B is wrong as - the theory is supported in the third para ( Important yet inconclusive experimental support for this theory comes from laboratory experiments with mice)
Second para do not talk about osteoporosis in human beings - so the last line of the third para is not applicable here. ( unfortunately............)
Join the discussion

by patanjali.purpose » Tue Jan 31, 2012 1:28 pm
OA - E
Join the discussion

by sai.99.gmat » Tue Jan 31, 2012 8:11 pm
Nice one Patanjali..whats the source?

The choice should have been rephrased to 'PLAUSIBLE' and not possible :P ....hahahaa

Technically it may sound right for one reason, the passage did not conclude by refuting the find ?

Avik? Other experts?
Join the discussion

by avik.ch » Tue Jan 31, 2012 10:32 pm
i agree with sai.99 on this. No idea about how E is the answer.

Where is the "solution" for Osteoporosis? I couldnt find it in the passage.

Malaria ------> mechanism how it occurs : I do not think that there is any solution here.

Malaria ------> mechanism how it occurs ----- > based on that, vaccines are created : here there is a solution

------

Not sure on this !!
Join the discussion