My answer to this question = B. As a few people noted, Statement 1 is insufficient by itself since (6,2) yields a positive response while (6,4) yields a negative response.
Another way of writing X^2 - Y^2 = (X+Y)(X-Y)
Statement 2 says that (X+Y) is divisible by 8. So, (X+Y) is some multiple of 8. Regardless of the value of (X-Y), one of the factors of this product is 8. For instance, if (X+Y) = 16, the two factors of this product are 8 and 2*(X-Y).
Thus, X^2 - Y^2 is divisible by 8, and Statement 2 is sufficient on its own.
I'm really old, but I'll never be too old to become more educated.