Appositive Usage - General Question

[uwhusky]

It is my understanding that appositive should modify the nearest noun, but at the same time, I see examples in the OG in which appositive modifies the head of the of-preposition instead of the object noun of the preposition. My question is, can an appositive modify both the object of an of-preposition and the head noun of a of-preposition? Is this one of those things that aren't set in stone?

[niksworth]

Indeed an appositive generally modifies the noun which it immediately follows. But this is not set in stone. It can also modify the noun ahead of the preposition instead of the object of preposition.

E.g. - Tashonda's goal in life, to become an occupational therapist, is within her grasp this year, at last. - Here the appositive to become an occupational therapist is modifying goal, the noun ahead of the preposition in [See how I used an appositive in the last sentence in its conventional sense? ]

What it actually modifies has to come out of the sentence in focus.

[uwhusky]

Alright, so in some cases, you wouldn't necessarily eliminate an answer because an appositive doesn't appear to be modifying the object of the preposition, as long as it could be modifying the head noun of the preposition?

[niksworth]

Alright, so in some cases, you wouldn't necessarily eliminate an answer because an appositive doesn't appear to be modifying the object of the preposition, as long as it could be modifying the head noun of the preposition?

AND as long as it conveyed proper sense, yes I wouldn't.

[Brian@VeritasPrep]

Thanks for the invite to join in! My take:

1) The nice thing about the GMAT is that you don't have to thoroughly understand all the rules of English (otherwise I'd certainly be out of a job), but rather just the application of what's tested. I think niksworth's point is a phenomenal one - "as long as it conveyed proper sense". If the modifier is logical in what it modifies, that's a much better general-case rule than trying to build an if-then flowchart that accounts for every case.

2) When a modifier includes a modifier, the appositive PHRASE needs to modify the word that comes next to it, but the words don't necessarily have to "touch":

The most popular girl in school, Marisa is captain of the softball team.

"in school" is kind of a necessary modifier...without it it's pretty nebulous how popular Marisa is (most popular in the world?). But using it pretty much dictates that it's going to separate "girl" from "Marisa". That's okay...the phrase is directly adjacent to her, so we know that it modifies her.

Again, the nice thing with the GMAT is that you always have choices to make between multiple options, so you don't have to know exactly what's right as long as you can recognize what's wrong. When in doubt, see if you can fall back on logic (does it make sense?) and that can be your guide through unclear situations.