BREAKING: Target Test Prep releases Brand New 2026 On Demand GMAT prep course

Redeem

Lets see what you think

Expert replies
by saitjordan » Tue Jan 27, 2009 12:30 pm
When a player in a certain game tossed a coin a number of times, 4 more heads than tails resulted. Heads or tails resulted each time the player tossed the coin. How many times did heads result?

1) The player tossed the coin 24 times.

2) The player received 3 points each time heads resulted and 1 point each time tails resulted, for a total of 52 points.
Join the discussion
Source: — Data Sufficiency |

by dmateer25 » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:14 pm
x = tail
x + 4 = heads

1) x + x + 4 =24
2x = 20
x=10

10 tails
14 heads

SUFF

2)
x + 3(x+4) = 52
x + 3x + 12 = 52
4x + 12 = 52
4x = 40
x = 10

10 tails
14 heads

SUFF

I choose D
Join the discussion

BUT

by saitjordan » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:20 pm
Firstly, according to the OG, you are correct.

BUT the question asks How many times DID heads result? Not, how many times was heads LIKELY to result. I feel like the assumption that heads will arise half of the time is just that, an assumption. And hence we cannot make any concrete conclusions about what the outcome will be. What do you think?
Join the discussion

by dmateer25 » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:26 pm
We know concretely that the coin was flipped 24 times and that with those 24 flips heads DID result 4 more times than tails.

This concretely tells us that heads must result 14 times and tails only 10.
Join the discussion

by gaggleofgirls » Tue Jan 27, 2009 6:58 pm
From the stem:
heads = tails + 4; h=t+4

1) 24 = h + t
24 = t+4+t
24 = 2t + 4
20 = 2t
t = 10
h = 10 + 4
h = 14
1 is sufficient

2) 52 = 3h + t
52 = 3(t+4) +t
52 = 3t + 12 +t
52 = 4t+12
40= 4t
10 = t
h = t + 4
h = 14
2 is sufficient

Answer = D

-Carrie
Join the discussion

Re: BUT

by gaggleofgirls » Tue Jan 27, 2009 7:03 pm
saitjordan wrote:I feel like the assumption that heads will arise half of the time is just that, an assumption.
None of the solutions given assume that heads will occur half the time. If heads occured half the time, then, when there are 24 coin tosses, 12 of them would be heads.

The stem said that "4 more heads than tails resulted."

From that, we know that total = tails+4 +tails

If the coin had been flipped 4 times, there would have been 4 heads and 0 tails - hardly heads arising half the time.

The only thing in the question that seems necessary is, "Heads or tails resulted each time the player tossed the coin." A coin is a 2-sided object. Anytime it is flipped, it will land on either one side or the other.

-Carrie
Join the discussion

by ontopofit » Sat Jan 31, 2009 2:38 am
For your clarity-
forget abt probability.
Let the no. of times head comes be A.
the no. of times tail comes be B

Given A-B = 4

1) A+B = 24;hence A is 14
2) 3A +B =52:hence A is 14

So,both 1) and 2) are sufficient.
D
Join the discussion