rohu27 wrote:vineeshp wrote:Wonder why the experts dont reply to Verbal as often as they do to Quant questions.
I really want to know why C is correct and B is wrong.
i read somehwere by one of the experts that they are too concerned abt the quality of materials posted here. random sources, unofficial ones, dubious answer chocies, incorrect questions - not to say all but there are enough to turn the experts away who always advise us (and correctly so) to study only from reliable sources.
and also they are concerned whn the posts get too technical - SC is all about eliminating choices and gettin to the right one, not to dissect each and evry answer choice to the bare and improve our grammar skills.
I think it's the latter that keeps experts away, more than the former. It's pretty easy to say "hey that is a terrible Verbal question, three of the answers are grammatically correct." Quant is, simply put, more bound by fixed rules and strategies than Verbal is, so it is easier to answer questions with definitive answers. Not only is what is "correct" in a language always debatable -- dictionaries publishing new editions have to put together panels of usage "experts" who talk about what "sounds right" to them -- but we are dealing with GMAT grammar, which is in turn a subset of actual real-life English grammar. There are grammatically-correct wrong answers in the OG!
So we are faced with the same impossible task you are -- sifting through what experts say, what the OG says, and what test prep sources you all find on the internet say about correct English, and trying form a cohesive set of rules and strategies for a much larger, more fluid, and (because none of us actually make the GMAT) ultimately unknowable data set, compared to Quant. Verbal is much more complex than Quant (not that Quant is somehow easy!).
Of course, I lurk in SC more than anywhere else because I think grammar is really fun (:(), and enjoy talking about it with people who learned English grammatically.