If x < 0, Is y > 0 ?
1) x/y < 0
2) y-x > 0
Well, we know x is negative from the question itself, and we're asked if y is positive. So we'll need some relationship between x and y that helps us determine y's signage.
Statement one says that the quotient of x/y will be negative. This can only happen when a positive number and a negative number are the terms. We already know x is negative, therefore y must be the positive term. This statement alone is sufficient.
Statement two can be rewritten y > x, but this leaves open the possibilities that y is a greater negative number than x ( -1 > -2) or that y is zero or that y is positive. So this statement is insufficient.
The correct answer is A
Is Y > 0 ?
This topic has expert replies
Source: Beat The GMAT — Data Sufficiency |
-
vittalgmat
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 621
- Joined: Wed Apr 09, 2008 7:13 pm
- Thanked: 33 times
- Followed by:4 members
Stmt 1 says that x /y is -ve number.
This can only happen if either x or y is negative (but not both).
we know x is -ve. So y is +ve.
Sufficient.
stmt 2: y -x > 0
=> y > x.
Now x is -ve. All that the stmt 2 says is that y is greater than x.
y could be -ve or +ve as long as y > x.
so insufficient.
HT Helps
This can only happen if either x or y is negative (but not both).
we know x is -ve. So y is +ve.
Sufficient.
stmt 2: y -x > 0
=> y > x.
Now x is -ve. All that the stmt 2 says is that y is greater than x.
y could be -ve or +ve as long as y > x.
so insufficient.
HT Helps
