Our views on the GMAT change in 2011

This topic has expert replies
User avatar
Senior | Next Rank: 100 Posts
Posts: 42
Joined: Mon Oct 05, 2009 11:02 pm
Location: India
Thanked: 4 times
GMAT Score:750

Our views on the GMAT change in 2011

by georgeanand » Fri Apr 01, 2011 8:28 pm
GMAT change ....and for the better.
The news about the replacement of one of the essays on the GMAT with an 'integrated reasoning section' is splashed all over the place.
The current scenario
The GMAT has been a reasonably good indicator of one's aptitude given that it tests quantitative, reasoning and verbal areas involving a good range of component skills- reasoning in a quantitative setting, ability to interpret and conclude from verbal data, identify, analyse and evaluate arguments to list a few. The writing section also tests, to some extent, analytical and evaluation skills. The argument essay prompts test one's ability to analyse and evaluate arguments similar to critical reasoning questions of the verbal section

Now one step ahead
No doubt the new change is in the forward direction. The integrated reasoning section appears to incorporate more complexities that would better reflect the modern day Bschool rigour. If reports were to be believed, the new test design would integrate data in numbers, symbols and words. This involves skills similar to those necessary to critically analyse, assemble and evaluate data collected from various sources and of various forms (audio, tabular and textual) into meaningful new inferences and conclusions that form the case studies and project assignments that constitute B school work.

Don't these also reflect as well as test an aspirant's ability to assimilate complex data drawn from various sources, processed and used in the world of business decision making?

Which essay topic can be dropped?
If I can be allowed to speculate, I would say the argument essay may be dropped. I present two cases for this guess

A.Critical reasoning of the verbal section tests the same skills as those in argument essay. in fact one can see a lot of overlaps between the two, except the skill of verbalizing one's reasoning

B.The proposed 'integrated reasoning' section can test more complex reasoning skills that the current argument essay task tests.

www.gmatsuperia.com
Have fun cracking GMAT
https://letsgmat.blocked
www.semanticslearning.com
GMAT classes at chennai,India
Source: — GMAT Strategy |

User avatar
MBA Student
Posts: 91
Joined: Wed Apr 06, 2011 5:54 pm
Location: Cambridge, Massachusetts
Thanked: 46 times
Followed by:26 members
GMAT Score:760

by therealtomrose » Fri Apr 15, 2011 9:10 am
I can't agree more that the new GMAT section is probably a good idea. We have known for some time that the essay section is basically useless. I typically council my students to simply get through it and try to stay relaxed for the "real" GMAT.

I hope that they replace the argument essay. You're right that the argument essay basically overlaps with CR.

Here's a question. How will the new score be calculated? Will this be part of the essay score out of 6.0, or will it be integrated into the 800, OR will there be a third component of the score. I vote (my useless vote) that it be kept as part of the essay score out of 6.0.

You may have noticed that the percentile roll-off on the essay scores is quite rapid. That is, by the time you get down to a score of 4.5, you are already at ~50 percentile. What this means is that for many test takers, the essay section is really just a test of whether you know english. It's not 'can you write well', it's just 'can you write?'

I hope that the integrated reasoning section linearizes the percentile rankings a bit more so that we can get more definition out of that part of the GMAT score.

While we're on the subject, GMAC really needs to get rid of the 800, 6.0 score format and just go to a single score total like the SAT. Make the essay out of 200 and just add it on top so the test is out of 1000. Something like that.

T
Like the advice? Remember to click the "thank" button. It's my only source of gratification :)

-Tom Rose

MIT Sloan MBA, Class of 2011
The MBA Show: https://www.TheMBAShow.com

Full disclosure, I work for
ManhattanGMAT: https://www.manhattangmat.com/gmat-tutor-rose.cfm