IMO the answer should be D
1- we have XYX=X - XY=X/X or 1 - sufficient
2- the same
are you sure in the official answer???
try this out
This topic has expert replies
Source: Beat The GMAT — Data Sufficiency |
-
jimmiejaz
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 207
- Joined: Sun Mar 11, 2007 6:16 pm
- Location: Mumbai
- Thanked: 11 times
We cant do like this..ershovici wrote:IMO the answer should be D
1- we have XYX=X - XY=X/X or 1 - sufficient
2- the same
are you sure in the official answer???
By your method we are ignoring a possible solution.
XYX - X=0
X(XY-1)=0
X=0 or XY=1
By your method, we are ignoring the solution X=0.... Hope this helps..
What if i have not yet beat the beast, I know i will beat it!!!!!!!!
-
Stuart@KaplanGMAT
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 3225
- Joined: Tue Jan 08, 2008 2:40 pm
- Location: Toronto
- Thanked: 1710 times
- Followed by:614 members
- GMAT Score:800
Jimmiejazz aptly points out the most common error people make in this situation - simply dividing both sides by a variable.jimmiejaz wrote:Is XY=1?
1.) XYX=X
2.) YXY=Y
Please comment..
We need to be careful when dividing by variables, since by doing so we're assuming that the variable doesn't equal 0.
The safer way to solve is to get everything over to one side and then factor, just as you would when solving a quadratic. For example:
1) x^2*y = x
x^2*y - x = 0
x(xy - 1) = 0
x = 0 or xy = 1
2) y^2*x = y
y^2*x - y = 0
y(xy - 1) = 0
y = 0 or xy = 1
Now here's the tricky part - at first glance, it looks like the only solution that the statements have in common is xy=1. However, 0 is a tricksy number; if x=y=0 then we still satisfy both statments.
So, we could have:
xy = 1, a "yes" answer; or
x=y=0, a "no" answer.
Even together, we can get both a yes and a no answer: insufficient, choose E.
Stuart Kovinsky | Kaplan GMAT Faculty | Toronto
Kaplan Exclusive: The Official Test Day Experience | Ready to Take a Free Practice Test? | Kaplan/Beat the GMAT Member Discount
BTG100 for $100 off a full course
I would have picked C based on this. Statement 1 gives us either x=0 or xy=1, statement 2 gives us either y=0 or xy=1. Combine the statements and xy=1!Stuart Kovinsky wrote: Now here's the tricky part - at first glance, it looks like the only solution that the statements have in common is xy=1. However, 0 is a tricksy number; if x=y=0 then we still satisfy both statments.
So, we could have:
xy = 1, a "yes" answer; or
x=y=0, a "no" answer.
Even together, we can get both a yes and a no answer: insufficient, choose E.
Stuart, how do we avoid this trap? I could easily see myself during test day, with the time pressure and all, picking C because both statements have xy=1... Are you saying to always double-check when the solution is zero?
-
jimmiejaz
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 207
- Joined: Sun Mar 11, 2007 6:16 pm
- Location: Mumbai
- Thanked: 11 times
Thanks for the explanation Stuart!!!
So The takeaway of this problem is Pls recheck the solution to a DS question where the answers contain 0 in both answer choices. Combined, they can provide a solution and therefore can change the correct answer choice.
Hope this helps.
So The takeaway of this problem is Pls recheck the solution to a DS question where the answers contain 0 in both answer choices. Combined, they can provide a solution and therefore can change the correct answer choice.
Hope this helps.
What if i have not yet beat the beast, I know i will beat it!!!!!!!!
