Ask Clear Admit

I have been working for a start-up non-profit for the last 6+ years and plan on going into consulting after graduation. I have been admitted to Georgeotwn, Virginia and Northwestern, with Duke hopefully coming soon.

That said, my decision is essentially between Virginia and Northwestern. I loved everything about the Darden experience, from Charlottesville, to the case study method, the close-knit community, and the beautiful campus. Northwestern hasn't really done anything wrong, per say, but I just didn't get the same great vibe.

My question is: would I be making a mistake in passing up Northwestern to go to Virginia, especially given that, a) Northwestern is a better school by most accounts, and b) it sends more graduates to top consulting firms?

I don't really have relevant work experience to fall back on (when applying to consulting firms) so I'm thinking it's more important I go to the best school and I'm guessing Kellogg has a great community too that I just didn't get to experience given my short stay (there for less than a day).

As much as I want to enjoy my experience, I understand the decades after school are far more important than the two short years in school, so my gut is to go to the school that gives me the best chance to succeed and that's Northwestern. Would you agree?

Thanks for your help!

Congratulations on your acceptances! You are fortunate to be in the position of deciding between two great programs. The best advice I can give is to visit both schools. It sounds like you spent time at Darden, but have you visted Kellogg? I encourage you to attend the admitted student's weekend at both programs. Not only are these weekends great for getting a sense of the culture of the school, but you'll also meet potential future classmates. These connections can help you make an informed decision.

I have a few thoughts on your consulting question given my role in MBA recruiting at McKinsey. If you are looking at joining a top tier firm your odds are likely hiring of landing a job by attending Kellogg. Just last year McKinsey's hiring at the school skyrocketed. If you are looking at joining a boutique firm or a larger brand (think Deloitte) then either school will suit your needs just fine.

Best,

Stacey