Profile Evaluation/Opinions

Free advice from the world's top MBA consultants
This topic has expert replies
Newbie | Next Rank: 10 Posts
Posts: 3
Joined: Wed Mar 04, 2015 7:00 pm

Profile Evaluation/Opinions

by chitown84 » Wed Mar 04, 2015 7:41 pm
Hi All,

I am considering applying full time for an MBA program and I would very much appreciate any advice or opinions on my chances as well as thought process.

About me:

Male, 30 years old, white.

GMAT- have not taken, but I took a few practice exams and ranged from 690-720. I am a strong test taker and feel that I can certainly crack 700 in the real deal.

GPA- Graduated in 2008 from a state school with a finance/accounting degree and a 3.0 GPA. Simply put, I did not have the time that most students did as I worked part time throughout and was a much different (read: immature) worker than I am now.

Work experience- coming up on seven years in the financial services industry, alternative investment asset servicing (middle/back office.) I have a very strong track record of promotions- I managed people (teams ranged from 2-8 reports) for 5 years and did all the requisite hiring, firing, and development of human capital. My most recent promotion was to a much more visible role within my firm, where I no longer have direct reports but instead work on the business side and manage several key client relationships. While I no longer have direct reports, my level of responsibility has increased exponentially. My path at this point would be to move into a business development-type role. I started out in the back office of a financial conglomerate in a small city, did a mid-term overseas assignment, and networked my way to a big city where I am now. My salary has increased significantly over the years (approximately 160%)

Extra curricular- I am active in my firm's community service group where I initiated and organized many fund raising activities, and I am an active member of a non-work sponsored mentor program.

Other achievements- I am active physically, run some marathons, etc. Running a triathlon this summer. CFA Level 2 candidate (more on this below.)

Now, as far as why I want to apply FT- interestingly enough, I was pretty set on a path into portfolio management and/or business development which is why I started the CFA program. I do have a passion for finance, and the CFA was equal parts hobby and career driven (it is not required in my current role.) As I progressed through the first level and now into level 2, I reignited a spark for learning that I have not felt for the last few years- I got pretty comfortable with a (low) six figure income and great work/life balance and sort of put off the MBA in favor of an EMBA down the road. Now that I am starting to feel the draw of learning again, I am right on the cusp of being a tad too old for a full time MBA and have started considering applying in the fall a finance heavy program (Booth is my target.) While I enjoy my current role, I am again finding myself drawn to the learning and the networking that comes with a full time program. This is not driven by financial motivation as much as it is a desire to learn from others and challenge myself outside of the corporate world.

In terms of my application- I think there are a few strong points:

-Work experience. While it's not a prestigious role, I think that given where I started (and when- 2008 crisis) I have made a nice progression that is based on my work ethic, personal brand and leadership skills.

-I have one senior person I could get a great letter of recommendation from- someone who has worked with me professionally and charitably.

-GMAT. Although I can't really say much now because I haven't taken it, I am a very strong test taker. I took the GRE coming out of school and was close to the 95th percentile in math and verbal without much effort. I'm confident this would be above 700, maybe close to 740-750.

Now, the weaknesses:

-Demographic- 30, white, male. Not much to say there.

-Other letter of recommendation would probably have to be from my most recent former boss... my current one would be quite unhappy knowing that I would be applying FT. Part time would be an easy ask, though.

-Age. Although I'm not sure I am TOO old, I think I am on the border.

-Future plans. Even I am not 100% sure what I want to do, and I almost wonder if the CFA program would work against me ("why are you applying if you are interested in PM?)

I have definitely considered part time, and would be on board with that except for the fact that my current employer has a very meager tuition reimbursement plan with a nasty clawback attached to it. Frankly, I don't love the firm I work for and would probably want to get out. And it goes without saying that part of the reason I want to go back is to explore other career paths outside of my current one.

I am interested to hear any opinions on the strengths/weaknesses of my profile as well as my rationale for applying- all input is appreciated.

Thanks!
Source: — Ask an MBA Admissions Consultant |

GMAT/MBA Expert

User avatar
Legendary Member
Posts: 1088
Joined: Thu Apr 18, 2013 3:29 pm
Thanked: 171 times
Followed by:52 members

by CriticalSquareMBA » Sat Mar 07, 2015 6:28 am
Hi there,

Thanks for sharing your profile - love the detail! You certainly have some things going for you, but I'm glad you took the time to consider the potential weak spots of your candidacy as well.

Your academic history isn't as strong, so you'll want to aim for the 720-740 range. You have some decent work experience - the most important aspect here is your growth in your roles and responsibilities, which is pretty clear, however given your age, it also may be expected. I only mention this because your rise within your firm (while good) isn't something we can really hang your hat on to differentiate you, so it will be critical to dig deeper into your story and bring out things that make you unique (personal interests, hobbies, etc.)

It's great to see that you've been involved in something outside of work. The mentor program sounds interesting - did you have a major impact here? Leadership in EC's is what oftentimes makes the difference.

As far as your justification for applying, I feel like I'm missing a bit of information here. What do you want to do post-MBA? It's great that you're feeling the itch to go back to school and that you've realized that you don't want to stay at your current firm forever, but we need to have an end game. At this stage it sounds like you're still figuring that out (which is OK), but in thinking about school selection, fit, and candidacy, the short and long term goals are critical in ensuring that your roadmap makes sense. We'll want to make sure we identify schools that are aligned to your candidacy as well as one that will give you the best shot at achieving your post-MBA goals (aligning concentration, involvement activities, and potential employers that recruit at certain programs).

Hope this information helps. Unfortunately, forums only let us get so far, so if you want to chat some more, feel free to reach out to chat with us!

Thanks!
Critical Square | MBA Admissions Services

Web | Facebook | Twitter

Sign up for a free consultation today!

We love helping! Was this post helpful to you? Thank us and let me know!