Hello Stacy! Could you help evaluate my target schools?

Launched April 26, 2006
This topic has expert replies
Newbie | Next Rank: 10 Posts
Posts: 7
Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2012 3:46 pm
Followed by:1 members
I just posted this in the MBA program selection forum - so I hope reposting it here will not be considered spam! I have read you blogs for some time, and would be humbled to receive your input.

I have unconventional work experience (non profit mgmt), which could be a benefit or a detriment, depending on how my story "reads" to adcoms. I will try to give some context to my stats.

Basic: 27 y/o white male (28 at matriculation). American.

GMAT: 700. 95th % verbal, 63% quant. I really screwed up timing on the quant section ( I usually score mid 80th % on practice tests). Retaking next Monday in hopes of raising quant to 80+ %tile. Quite confident that I can.

Education: 3.6 from UCSD. Major: Chinese Studies; Minor: Political Science. Spent 8 months studying in china. Upward grade trajectory. Also received a merit scholarship from UCSD to take extension classes in non profit development, as well as finance. Straight A's in those classes (several accounting/finance classes included).

Work Experience: 3 years at a non profit assisting wounded veterans. Started as grants coordinator, promoted to program director, and then to executive director. Progressive responsibilities correlating to each position - I have gained a deep understanding of non profits from several angles (program implementation, evaluation, fundraising, management, strategic planning, marketing, etc). The organization is relatively small, but quite established with national programs. You would probably not recognize the name, however.

Awards: the scholarship mentioned above, as well as a commendation from the brig. general in charge of special operations in ft. bragg (not a huge deal)

Extra curriculars: volunteered at a boarding school/orphanage in Kathmandu, Nepal for several weeks, but that was quite some time ago. Nothing notable in college (see explanation below) or post college, as my job/organization consumes my 'volunteer time'. Conversational in mandarin and spanish - though it is a goal of mine to become 100% fluent in chinese. Lots of traveling, in both developed and developing countries.

Goals: I chose my major out of an interest in the subject, and a genuine desire to help others. I figured It would be a great background to have, but would require an advanced degree to narrow its focus. I wanted to be a foreign service officer (state dept) working on small business development pertaining to china. My father got sick shortly after I transferred to UCSD (brain tumor), and passed away within a year. I spent most of my free time during college with him/my family. Due to my family situation, I chose to remain in San Diego after graduation to provide support. I came from a military family, so the cause of my current organization resonated strongly with me - I am lucky to be able to "work" for such a great cause. I found that I am most passionate about working on social/organizational issues from a strategic standpoint. I would like to get an MBA and work in non profit consulting (preferably international) dealing with larger organizations. Companies such as bridgespan typically recruit from top MBA programs. Long term, I would like to utilize my background in Chinese studies with a NGO operating in the region / on the issues, or perhaps realize a niche to fill with an organization of my own. I could make my passion shine through in admission essays - I'm writing this from an iPad, so my syntax is quite terse at the moment.

What schools should I target? Is top 10 way out of line? I know it will be a crapshoot, considering my unconventional background & goals. In my wildest dreams, I would be interested in Stanford/HBS, Haas, Yale, Northwestern, or UCLA. If that is unrealistic, are there any other social entrepreneurship / non profit mgmt programs I should be looking into?

Thank you! Sorry for the wall of text.
Source: — Ask Stacy Blackman |

Newbie | Next Rank: 10 Posts
Posts: 7
Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2012 3:46 pm
Followed by:1 members

by SocialImpactMBA » Sat Nov 24, 2012 1:39 pm
So, I'm retaking the GMAT the day after tomorrow. Assuming that I can raise my quant score to 80th percentile or above, i would like some input on realistic schools to send the score to.

Any insights would be EXTREMELY appreciated!

Newbie | Next Rank: 10 Posts
Posts: 7
Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2012 3:46 pm
Followed by:1 members

by SocialImpactMBA » Mon Nov 26, 2012 11:30 pm
So, I re-took the GMAT this afternoon - and ended up with the exact same score! 41V/44Q, for a 700.

After all of my online reading, the conclusion that I have drawn is that admission to top programs is a crap shoot. Some people say that a low quantitative score can be offset by a quant focused undergrad degree/work experience, while others claim that a low-ish quant score can be forgiven if you have a weak quant background, but have taken some quant classes to supplement your stats.

I took some accounting/finance classes from UC extension that were quant heavy - and got A's in them. While I am not happy with my GMAT quant percentile (63), I also understand that a raw score of 44Q isn't necessarily terrible, and may be skewed by a large number of engineering applicants.

Also, please consider that I am coming from a humanities / non-profit background with solid leadership experience. Nothing too quant heavy. I'm assuming that the GMAT quant score will be lower for applicants with my profile. Is this the case?

My question now is this: is it worth my time even considering a top10 school with a 44Q? Again, I am confident that I can spin a cohesive story in my application about 'why an MBA, why now', as well as draw on some non-traditional work experience to grab the attention of the Adcoms. That being said, I don't want to waste my time and money applying for programs that are going to toss my app in the 'reject' pile based on the low-ish GMAT quant score.

Any advice?