A question from 1000 Series

This topic has expert replies
Newbie | Next Rank: 10 Posts
Posts: 4
Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2011 9:25 pm

A question from 1000 Series

by saurabh_wakhare » Thu Jun 21, 2012 5:02 am
The chanterelle, a type of wild mushroom, grows
beneath host trees such as the Douglas fir, which
provide it with necessary sugars. The underground
filaments of chanterelles, which extract the sugars,
in turn provide nutrients and water for their hosts.
Because of this mutually beneficial relationship,
harvesting the chanterelles growing beneath a
Douglas fir seriously endangers the tree.

Which of the following, if true, casts the most doubt
on the conclusion drawn above?
(A) The number of wild mushrooms harvested has
increased in recent years.
(B) Chanterelles grow not only beneath Douglas firs
but also beneath other host trees.
(C) Many types of wild mushrooms are found only
in forests and cannot easily be grown
elsewhere.
(D) The harvesting of wild mushrooms stimulates
future growth of those mushrooms.
(E) Young Douglas fir seedlings die without the
nutrients and water provided by chanterelle
filaments.

I suppose, option (E) would be the correct choice, but according to the answer sheet (D) has been proffered over (E)
Please help me to understand.
Source: — Critical Reasoning |

User avatar
Legendary Member
Posts: 502
Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2008 11:36 pm
Thanked: 99 times
Followed by:21 members

by vk_vinayak » Thu Jun 21, 2012 9:15 am
Conclusion:harvesting the chanterelles growing beneath a Douglas fir seriously endangers the tree.

(D) The harvesting of wild mushrooms stimulates future growth of those mushrooms.
>> If harvesting stimulates the future growth, mushrooms will be grown again, helping the Douglas fir. So, Douglas fir will not become extinct.

(E) Young Douglas fir seedlings die without the nutrients and water provided by chanterelle filaments.
>> I assume we are talking about harvesting mushrooms that are growing under Douglas fir tree, not the young Dougls seedlings.
Even if we are talking about young Douglas seedlings, if the young Dougls seedling die without mushrooms, mushrooms will also die without young Douglas because mushrooms depend upon the necessary sugar provided by Douglas.

Hence I prefer D, which weakens the argument directly, to E.
- VK

I will (Learn. Recognize. Apply)