Inverted Sentences: Pronouns and Subject-Verb Agreement
This week we have yet another topic suggested by a student (keep the requests coming!), who recently asked me about various issues with pronoun case. Im going to address the students specific question but also expand on the topic a bit. The issues discussed here are advanced issues; you likely don't need to worry about these if your goal score is 650 or lower.
The question
Heres what the student asked:
I am not sure whether Hi, its me! or Hi, its I is correct. What about Its him who will answer or Its he who will answer?
First, the student is asking when to use different cases for singular first person or singular third person pronouns, so were dealing with pronoun case. Pronouns can come in three cases (though not all pronouns have three cases): subjective, objective, and possessive. The names of the cases refer to how the pronoun is used in the sentence.
Next, the student is questioning whether the subject is the pronoun it, before the verb in each sentence, or whether the subject comes after the verb (because we wouldnt use a subjective pronoun in that position unless it was the subject of the sentence). So the student is also questioning whether we have an inverted sentence.
Pronoun Cases
Here are the cases for personal pronouns:
[raw]
| Subjective | Objective | Possessive | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st person (singular) | I | me | my, mine |
| 2nd person (singular) | you | you | your, yours |
| 3rd person (masculine singular) | he | him | his |
| 3rd person (feminine singular) | she | her | her, hers |
| 3rd person (neutral singular) | it | it | its |
| 1st person plural | we | us | our, ours |
| 2nd person plural | you | you | your, yours |
| 3rd person plural | they | them | their, theirs |
[/raw]
Subjective pronouns are used as subjects in sentences. Objective pronouns are used as objects. Possessive pronouns are used when we want to indicate some kind of possession. For example:
I ate the pizza. I is the subject, so we use a subjective pronoun. The pizza is the object.
The pizza was eaten by me. The pizza is now the subject and me is the object, so we use an objective pronoun.
That pizza is mine. The pizza is still the subject, but this time, Im indicating possession: the pizza belongs to me. Therefore, I use the possessive pronoun mine.
Inverted Sentences
So far, the examples weve used are pretty straightforward and, chances are, you would not be confused if asked to choose between I ate the pizza and Me ate the pizza. How do things get more complicated on the GMAT?
One way to make a more complicated sentence is to invert the subject to place the subject after the verb rather than before. For example, the 11th edition of The Official Guide for GMAT Review (OG) included this clause in one SC problem:
it will be difficult to absorb them
In this case, the subject is actually the infinitive phrase to absorb them and the non-inverted sentence would read to absorb them will be difficult. Awkward, yes, but grammatically correct!
When we invert the subject in this way, we have to use some kind of pronoun before the verb as a placeholder to indicate that were postponing the subject. In the above sentence, the pronoun it functions as the placeholder, but that pronoun is not the subject of the sentence. (Note: The pronoun it can also function as a subject in a sentence; it just doesnt serve that purpose in the above sentence.)
Another example, from an incorrect answer in the 10th edition of OG, says:
there was at least a million or more others
In any sentence, the verb has to match with the subject, so its important for us to identify the subject correctly. The subject is the plural noun others, but the verb is the singular was. The sentence should read there were at least a million or more others and the non-inverted sentence would read at least a million or more others were
See what I did to non-invert both of those sentences? In the vast majority of cases, when an inverted subject is used correctly, you should be able to pick up the subject and put it in front of the verb to make an awkward-sounding but technically grammatically correct subject-verb pair. If that doesnt work, then you most likely dont have an inverted sentence and should look before the verb for the subject.
Which is Correct: Its me or Its I?
Lets look at the students question again. We have two options: either the it pronoun is functioning as the subject, or the it is indicating a postponed subject and we have an inverted sentence. Lets try them both out.
If it is functioning as the subject, then the pronoun after the verb should be in the objective case. Which one represents the objective case me or I? (Me.)
If it is functioning as a placeholder and the subject occurs after the verb, then the pronoun after the verb should be in the subjective case and the verb will need to match with that subject. The subjective pronoun is I, and the verb that goes with I is am (for example, I am here). So if we want to have an inverted subject here, wed have to say It am I! (Non-inverted: I am it!)
Hmm. That doesnt work so this isnt an inverted subject. It really is functioning as the subject, so we need to use the objective case for the pronoun: Its me.
What about the other one: Its him who will answer or Its he who will answer? In this case, we can say he is who will answer. We can consider this an inverted sentence, then, with he as the subject and use the form its he who will answer. (Though I will mention that this particular structure is not very common on the test. I dont think Ive seen an instance on the GMAT of an inverted structure that uses a pronoun as the subject. They tend to be more like the two OG examples I mentioned above.)
Take-Aways
- These are both advanced issues. If youre going for an 80th percentile or higher score on verbal only, you should know how to deal with them. If you are going for a 65th percentile or lower, dont worry too much about them. Finally, if youre aiming for somewhere between 65th and 80th percentile, study the more advanced material only in your areas of strength.
- If you need to study inverted sentences, know what an inverted sentence is and how to test whether one has been constructed properly.
- If you need to study pronoun case, know what the three cases are and how they are used.
Copyright note: the text excerpted above from The Official Guide for GMAT Review 11th Edition is copyright GMAC (the Graduate Management Admissions Council). The short excerpts are quoted under fair-use statutes for scholarly or journalistic work; use of these excerpts does not imply endorsement of this article by GMAC.