BREAKING: Target Test Prep releases Brand New 2026 On Demand GMAT prep course

Redeem

PROBABILITY QUESTION (PLEASE HELP!!!)

Expert replies
by Stockmoose16 » Tue Sep 09, 2008 2:38 pm
I desperately need someone to explain the difference between these two questions:

In a bag of 10 marbles, there are 6 white, 4 blue:

1) "What is the probability of getting a white marble and blue marble"

2) "What is the probability of first picking a white marble, then picking a blue one?

These two questions sound exactly the same to me, but according to my GMAT book, have two different answers. Can someone explain the difference between the two questions in layman's terms?
Join the discussion
Source: — Problem Solving |

Stockmoose16 wrote:I desperately need someone to explain the difference between these two questions:

In a bag of 10 marbles, there are 6 white, 4 blue:

1) "What is the probability of getting a white marble and blue marble"

2) "What is the probability of first picking a white marble, then picking a blue one?

These two questions sound exactly the same to me, but according to my GMAT book, have two different answers. Can someone explain the difference between the two questions in layman's terms?
"What is the probability of getting a white marble and blue marble"

= 6/10 * 4/9 + 4/10 * 6/9

= 4/15 + 4/15 = 8/15 [here order of picking marbles is not mentioned, therefore you have consider both the possibilities]

"What is the probability of first picking a white marble, then picking a blue one?

= 6/10*4/9 = 4/15


Hope this helps.
Join the discussion

parallel_chase wrote:
Stockmoose16 wrote:I desperately need someone to explain the difference between these two questions:

In a bag of 10 marbles, there are 6 white, 4 blue:

1) "What is the probability of getting a white marble and blue marble"

2) "What is the probability of first picking a white marble, then picking a blue one?

These two questions sound exactly the same to me, but according to my GMAT book, have two different answers. Can someone explain the difference between the two questions in layman's terms?
"What is the probability of getting a white marble and blue marble"

= 6/10 * 4/9 + 4/10 * 6/9

= 4/15 + 4/15 = 8/15 [here order of picking marbles is not mentioned, therefore you have consider both the possibilities]

"What is the probability of first picking a white marble, then picking a blue one?

= 6/10*4/9 = 4/15


Hope this helps.
Can you please explain why the order makes any difference? (effectively doubling the answer?)
Join the discussion

Stockmoose16 wrote: Can you please explain why the order makes any difference? (effectively doubling the answer?)
The order makes a difference in probability since we are not given any order of picking marbles, like there was in second part of the question.

We are not doubling anything. We are just calculating the total probable combination of picking marbles.
Join the discussion