BREAKING: Target Test Prep releases Brand New 2026 On Demand GMAT prep course

Redeem

Hospital Report

Expert replies
by komal » Thu Feb 11, 2010 12:31 am
The report recommended that the hospital should eliminate unneeded beds, expensive services should be consolidated, and use space in other hospitals.

(A) should eliminate unneeded beds, expensive services should be consolidated, and use space in other hospitals

(B) should eliminate unneeded beds, expensive services should be consolidated, and other hospitals' space be used

(C) should eliminate unneeded beds, expensive services should be consolidated, and to use space in other hospitals

(0) eliminate unneeded beds, consolidate expensive services, and other hospitals' space used

(E) eliminate unneeded beds, consolidate expensive services, and use space in other hospitals

OA E
Join the discussion
Source: — Sentence Correction |

by thephoenix » Thu Feb 11, 2010 1:39 am
komal wrote:The report recommended that the hospital should eliminate unneeded beds, expensive services should be consolidated, and use space in other hospitals.

(A) should eliminate unneeded beds, expensive services should be consolidated, and use space in other hospitals

(B) should eliminate unneeded beds, expensive services should be consolidated, and other hospitals' space be used

(C) should eliminate unneeded beds, expensive services should be consolidated, and to use space in other hospitals

(0) eliminate unneeded beds, consolidate expensive services, and other hospitals' space used

(E) eliminate unneeded beds, consolidate expensive services, and use space in other hospitals

OA E
case of llelism
the three itmes listed below needs to be llel
eliminate unneeded beds,
expensive services should be consolidated,
and use space in other hospitals.

only E does by starting each clause with averb
Join the discussion

by bhumika.k.shah » Thu Feb 11, 2010 2:56 am
Honestly speaking i dint know whether it should be should eliminate or just eliminate. But why wait for miracles to happen and ur brain to strike! :D

Move to finding the next error.

Now A , B and C each uses should @ the beginning of the sentence and again it uses should after a comma . Firstly its wordy and secondly its lacking parallelism.ELIMINATE

Left with D and E

D also lack parallelism since the correct form is eliminate, consolidate and use.

This is shown only by E

Hence I'd go with E

Hope this helps :)
komal wrote:The report recommended that the hospital should eliminate unneeded beds, expensive services should be consolidated, and use space in other hospitals.

(A) should eliminate unneeded beds, expensive services should be consolidated, and use space in other hospitals

(B) should eliminate unneeded beds, expensive services should be consolidated, and other hospitals' space be used

(C) should eliminate unneeded beds, expensive services should be consolidated, and to use space in other hospitals

(0) eliminate unneeded beds, consolidate expensive services, and other hospitals' space used

(E) eliminate unneeded beds, consolidate expensive services, and use space in other hospitals

OA E
Join the discussion

by mgmt_gmat » Thu Feb 11, 2010 5:12 am
parallelism for the fist two part and use space match eliminate..

two part parallelism

Hence (E)
Join the discussion

by happymanocha » Wed Jan 11, 2012 8:59 pm
I would like someone to review this question. As per MGMAT SC guide, verb recommended (bossy verb) should be used in the format

recommended+ THAT+ subject + command subjunctive. Can some one explain if there is any command subjunctive in this question? I understand the answer is E but would like to understand more about the Command subjunctives and why it is not required in this sentence.
Join the discussion

by e-GMAT » Thu Jan 12, 2012 9:54 am
happymanocha wrote:I would like someone to review this question. As per MGMAT SC guide, verb recommended (bossy verb) should be used in the format

recommended+ THAT+ subject + command subjunctive. Can some one explain if there is any command subjunctive in this question? I understand the answer is E but would like to understand more about the Command subjunctives and why it is not required in this sentence.
Hi,

Subjunctive verbs are used with the verbs that express demand, request, or recommendation. There is a list of verbs with which we can only use subjunctive words. "Recommend" is one such verb that requires the use of subjunctive verb, as very clear from the explanation of its usage.

Since this sentence uses the verb "recommend", we need subjunctive verb forms here. Hence the verbs to be used in this sentence should be "eliminate", "consolidate" and "use".

Although "hospital" is singular subjects and needs singular verb forms, use of "eliminate", "consolidate" and "use" is correct in the correct answer choice E because of the presence of the verb "recommended". This is a unique feature of subjunctive verbs. They do not follow the subject-verb number agreement rule. Subjunctive verbs must be used in their root form without any suffix.

Also the subjunctive verbs follow a particular structure which is:
Demand/Request/Recommend Word + THAT + Subject + Subjunctive Verb

Use of "that" is imperative when using subjunctive verbs.
This OG question has a similar structure:

The report recommended (Recommend Word) + "that" + "the hospital" (Subject) + "eliminate (Subjunctive Verb) unneeded beds", "consolidate (Subjunctive Verb) expensive services", and "use (Subjunctive Verb) space in other hospitals."

@bhumika.k.shah: I hope now you know why we need just "eliminate" in this sentence and not "should eliminate".

Thanks :-)
Shraddha

Image
Join the discussion

by gmatjeet » Thu Jan 12, 2012 11:26 am
HI Shradha,

If i interpret you correctly then the below sentence will be incorrect <because it uses SHOULD before subjunctive verb> <instead of following the format - Demand/Request/Recommend Word + THAT + Subject + Subjunctive Verb >

The report recommended that the hospital should eliminate unneeded beds, consolidate expensive services, and use space in other hospitals.
Join the discussion

by e-GMAT » Thu Jan 12, 2012 3:10 pm
gmatjeet wrote:HI Shradha,

If i interpret you correctly then the below sentence will be incorrect <because it uses SHOULD before subjunctive verb> <instead of following the format - Demand/Request/Recommend Word + THAT + Subject + Subjunctive Verb >

The report recommended that the hospital should eliminate unneeded beds, consolidate expensive services, and use space in other hospitals.
@gmatjeet: Yes. The sentence is incorrect because use of "should" before "eliminate" is incorrect.
Join the discussion

• Page 1 of 1