It should be D
The sample is not representative of all people
1000 CR TEST I Q 8
This topic has expert replies
Source: Beat The GMAT — Critical Reasoning |
I believe the OA should be D. I also believe that this question sucks.
"A study of the real estate industry, however, revealed that the current supply of homes could only provide for 65% of that demand each year."
Here, "that" is clearly referring to the 85% of the magazine's readers. It's not saying that the industry can only provide for 65% of the nation's population, but that it can only provide for 65% of the readers. Therefore, the statistic is completely representative of the market.
For simplicity's sake, let's use real numbers:
Assume that there are 100 magazine readers. 85 want a second home. The industry can only provide 55 houses. Obviously there is still a shortage, and investing in real estate can still be a good idea.
...Stupid GMAT; it tests anaphors in SC, but can't even create a proper antecedant in CR. :roll:
"A study of the real estate industry, however, revealed that the current supply of homes could only provide for 65% of that demand each year."
Here, "that" is clearly referring to the 85% of the magazine's readers. It's not saying that the industry can only provide for 65% of the nation's population, but that it can only provide for 65% of the readers. Therefore, the statistic is completely representative of the market.
For simplicity's sake, let's use real numbers:
Assume that there are 100 magazine readers. 85 want a second home. The industry can only provide 55 houses. Obviously there is still a shortage, and investing in real estate can still be a good idea.
...Stupid GMAT; it tests anaphors in SC, but can't even create a proper antecedant in CR. :roll:
-
reply2spg
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 1261
- Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2008 3:46 am
- Thanked: 27 times
- GMAT Score:570
IMO C here
I guess D is strengthen the argument. If reader are more likely want to buy house then it strengthen the argument
Does anyone has OA?
I guess D is strengthen the argument. If reader are more likely want to buy house then it strengthen the argument
Does anyone has OA?
Anonymous wrote:Investing in real estate would be a profitable venture at this time. A survey in House magazine revealed that 85% of the magazine�s readers are planning to buy a second home over the next few years. A study of the real estate industry, however, revealed that the current supply of homes could only provide for 65% of that demand each year.
8. Which of the following, if true, reveals a weakness in the evidence cited above?
(A) Real estate is a highly labor-intensive business.
(B) Home builders are not evenly distributed across the country.
(C) The number of people who want second homes has been increasing each year for the past ten years.
(D) Readers of House magazine are more likely than most people to want second homes.
(E) House magazine includes articles about owning a second home as well as articles about building a second home.
Sudhanshu
(have lot of things to learn from all of you)
(have lot of things to learn from all of you)
-
adi_800
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 544
- Joined: Thu Oct 08, 2009 9:14 am
- Location: Pune, India
- Thanked: 31 times
- Followed by:2 members
It could very well be the case that only readers of magazine are intending to buy homes and not others...So, if only readers are gonna buy more homes, then the 65% of the demand can be met for the readers of the magazine and not for other people.... So, if this is d case, then there is no point in investing in real estate...
-
FightWithGMAT
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 364
- Joined: Tue Apr 20, 2010 5:13 am
- Thanked: 31 times
- Followed by:3 members
IMO DAnonymous wrote:Investing in real estate would be a profitable venture at this time. A survey in House magazine revealed that 85% of the magazine�s readers are planning to buy a second home over the next few years. A study of the real estate industry, however, revealed that the current supply of homes could only provide for 65% of that demand each year.
8. Which of the following, if true, reveals a weakness in the evidence cited above?
(A) Real estate is a highly labor-intensive business.
(B) Home builders are not evenly distributed across the country.
(C) The number of people who want second homes has been increasing each year for the past ten years.
(D) Readers of House magazine are more likely than most people to want second homes.
(E) House magazine includes articles about owning a second home as well as articles about building a second home.
It is an issue of representativeness of the survey.
Magazine surveyed those people who are more inclined to buy second house. That is why there is a contrast in the two results.
-
FightWithGMAT
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 364
- Joined: Tue Apr 20, 2010 5:13 am
- Thanked: 31 times
- Followed by:3 members
Another good answer could be:FightWithGMAT wrote:IMO DAnonymous wrote:Investing in real estate would be a profitable venture at this time. A survey in House magazine revealed that 85% of the magazine�s readers are planning to buy a second home over the next few years. A study of the real estate industry, however, revealed that the current supply of homes could only provide for 65% of that demand each year.
8. Which of the following, if true, reveals a weakness in the evidence cited above?
(A) Real estate is a highly labor-intensive business.
(B) Home builders are not evenly distributed across the country.
(C) The number of people who want second homes has been increasing each year for the past ten years.
(D) Readers of House magazine are more likely than most people to want second homes.
(E) House magazine includes articles about owning a second home as well as articles about building a second home.
It is an issue of representativeness of the survey.
Magazine surveyed those people who are more inclined to buy second house. That is why there is a contrast in the two results.
The study encompassed those real estate dealers who do not have many housing projects.
