For the ball to be white OR Even the ball could be:
1) white AND even
2) not white and even
3) white and not even
the sum of all the above probabilities will give us the probabilty or White OR even.
so in (1) we are given the white and even - insuff
in (2) we are given white and not even - insuff
combined we still don't know how many not white and even so answer is E
gmat prep probability
This topic has expert replies
Source: Beat The GMAT — Data Sufficiency |
-
mike22629
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 322
- Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 3:56 pm
- Thanked: 24 times
- GMAT Score:710
When finding the Probability of Either/ Or:
Use the Formula
P(a) + p(b) = P(a or b)
(This is in Erics Flashcards on this site)
The first question tells you that it can not be both white and even, but no information on individual probabilities
The second tells you
p(a) - p(b) = .2
However; you need to know p(a) + p(b)
because the information in 2 can give you different answers.
If p(a) = .4 and p(b) = .2
then p(a or b) = .6
If p(a) = .3 and p(b)= .1
then p(a or b) = .4
Hence E
Use the Formula
P(a) + p(b) = P(a or b)
(This is in Erics Flashcards on this site)
The first question tells you that it can not be both white and even, but no information on individual probabilities
The second tells you
p(a) - p(b) = .2
However; you need to know p(a) + p(b)
because the information in 2 can give you different answers.
If p(a) = .4 and p(b) = .2
then p(a or b) = .6
If p(a) = .3 and p(b)= .1
then p(a or b) = .4
Hence E
-
bluementor
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 418
- Joined: Wed Jun 11, 2008 5:29 am
- Thanked: 65 times
-
fercho81
- Senior | Next Rank: 100 Posts
- Posts: 30
- Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 8:29 pm
- Location: new jersey
- GMAT Score:640
I solved this one using a Venn diagram; maybe it will be clearer. Make a Venn diagram, the circles will be white and even and the middle, where they intersect, will be white and even combined. Now, to get either white or even (like the question asks), we will need to get the numbers for both the white and even circles minus the middle, which as you know, we can’t count because the middle is white and even.
So if answers 1 & 2 give us the below we can answer the question:
Prob. of being white + Prob. of being even – Prob. of being white and even.
(1)Give us Prob. of being white and even, so this gives us the middle of the Venn diagram. Insufficient by itself
(2)This doesn’t help us to complete our equation above. Insufficient.
Now if you look at the two together you don’t have enough info to complete the equation, hence the answer is E. Hope this helped, just wanted to show a different way of solving this question.
So if answers 1 & 2 give us the below we can answer the question:
Prob. of being white + Prob. of being even – Prob. of being white and even.
(1)Give us Prob. of being white and even, so this gives us the middle of the Venn diagram. Insufficient by itself
(2)This doesn’t help us to complete our equation above. Insufficient.
Now if you look at the two together you don’t have enough info to complete the equation, hence the answer is E. Hope this helped, just wanted to show a different way of solving this question.
