BREAKING: Target Test Prep releases Brand New 2026 On Demand GMAT prep course

Redeem

complete the paragraph(CTP) in the most appropriate way

Expert replies
by harsh.champ » Sat Feb 06, 2010 2:36 am
Library shelves groan under an insupportable mass of volumes about the dreadful flea-borne pestilence that spread across Europe in the middle of the 14th century - the number of books being equaled only by the scores that deal with the very similar plague that killed thousands in London three centuries later. The Black Death, the Awful Malady, the Vast Pestilence, the Great Mortality, the plague has been called by many names, and is in many senses a perfect topic for the lazy historian - the subject matter is adequately horrifying, the known descriptions are vividly readable, the social implications are sufficiently varied to allow for the kind of wild speculations that make for a book publicist's dream.


(A)But the accounts that have resulted in the past all seem to tell in essence much the same story, and in the very same
way.
(B) Rumours are heard of distant illness, neighbours appear with lurid tales, and then suddenly local people become afflicted.
(C)That is the Black Death as sound bite, and rare is the account that manages to take it very much further.
(D)Huge swellings appear in groins and armpits, leaving thousands to be limed and buried, while stunned communities try
desperately to recover sanity and order.
(E)No wonder that centuries after it happened, the Black Death is still a bestseller.



The ans is E.
Join the discussion
Source: — Critical Reasoning |

by thephoenix » Sat Feb 06, 2010 2:44 am
hun!!!!
tough one is it A
Join the discussion

by harsh.champ » Sat Feb 06, 2010 5:19 am
thephoenix wrote:hun!!!!
tough one is it A
Sorry,the phoenix it is not A ,infact the answer is E.
The most important thing to keep in mind while completing a paragraph is that no extra information should be added to the passage.The next line should complete the passage keeping the theme of the passage in mind.
Also,even if you have prior knowledge of the subject you should try to resist using it.
Sometimes, the trap may be that considering the passage the ans. choice is different but if you apply your prior knowledge you can land up at a different option choice.
Join the discussion

by hrishi19884 » Sat Feb 06, 2010 5:55 am
harsh.champ wrote:Library shelves groan under an insupportable mass of volumes about the dreadful flea-borne pestilence that spread across Europe in the middle of the 14th century - the number of books being equaled only by the scores that deal with the very similar plague that killed thousands in London three centuries later. The Black Death, the Awful Malady, the Vast Pestilence, the Great Mortality, the plague has been called by many names, and is in many senses a perfect topic for the lazy historian - the subject matter is adequately horrifying, the known descriptions are vividly readable, the social implications are sufficiently varied to allow for the kind of wild speculations that make for a book publicist's dream.


(A)But the accounts that have resulted in the past all seem to tell in essence much the same story, and in the very same
way.
(B) Rumours are heard of distant illness, neighbours appear with lurid tales, and then suddenly local people become afflicted.
(C)That is the Black Death as sound bite, and rare is the account that manages to take it very much further.
(D)Huge swellings appear in groins and armpits, leaving thousands to be limed and buried, while stunned communities try
desperately to recover sanity and order.
(E)No wonder that centuries after it happened, the Black Death is still a bestseller.



The ans is E.
The best possible way I can get to the answer is:

1) Eliminate the choices that are unrelated to the topic.

Rules out B , C and D

2)A- has but(means contrast to the previous statement)

Now here, the last few lines indicates that author is positive that all the books would be famous even if a lazy historian writes the book due to various reasons(author provides various reasons for for the same).
So the sentence in B, starting with "but" should resist/oppose the conclusion drawn by the author.
But it indicates that it is the same story as in the past which strengthens the conclusion.
Hence we can rule that out easily.
Note: in case the sentence would have been ".....different story and in a different way". It might have been the answer.

E - does not use "but" but it uses "no wonder" which should also attack the conclusion drawn by author.
It does by saying that only "Black Death" of the so many books that are published is still the best one.
(this indicates others are not as better as this one---opposes the conclusion)
Hence E is the answer.
Hrishi

"As you sow, so shall you reap"
Join the discussion

by joseph32 » Sun May 15, 2016 11:09 pm
In my opinion A is the most logical one.
Join the discussion