Confusing absolute value problem
This topic has expert replies
Source: Beat The GMAT — Problem Solving |
Can you also provide explanation for answer choice [D]. It will be very interesting to understand the explantion. I think it will have to do something with the wording "could be true".
From OG11 DS explanation, what I understand is that
If |x| = +x, then x is zero or positive i.e. x >= 0
If |x| = -x , then x is zero or negative i.e. x <= 0
If both are true, then obviously x=0.
I think answer should be .
From OG11 DS explanation, what I understand is that
If |x| = +x, then x is zero or positive i.e. x >= 0
If |x| = -x , then x is zero or negative i.e. x <= 0
If both are true, then obviously x=0.
I think answer should be .
-
netigen
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 631
- Joined: Mon Feb 18, 2008 11:57 pm
- Thanked: 29 times
- Followed by:3 members
ash g wrote:Can you also provide explanation for answer choice [D]. It will be very interesting to understand the explantion. I think it will have to do something with the wording "could be true".
From OG11 DS explanation, what I understand is that
If |x| = +x, then x is zero or positive i.e. x >= 0
If |x| = -x , then x is zero or negative i.e. x <= 0
If both are true, then obviously x=0.
I think answer should be .
|x| is always positive for all x (thats the absolute value concept)
The explanation is given below but I was not able to make it out and hence the posting here:
Example: If x = ±|x| , then which one of the following statements could be true?
I. x = 0
II. x < 0
III. x > 0
(A) None (B) I only (C) III only (D) I and II (E) II and III
Statement I could be true because ±|0| = -(+0)= -(0) = 0 . Statement II could be true because the
right side of the equation is always negative [ ±|x| = –(a positive number) = a negative number].
Now, if one side of an equation is always negative, then the other side must always be negative,
otherwise the opposite sides of the equation would not be equal. Since Statement III is the
opposite of Statement II, it must be false. But let’s show this explicitly: Suppose x were positive.
Then |x| = x, and the equation x = ±|x| becomes x = –x. Dividing both sides of this equation by x
yields 1 = –1. This is contradiction. Hence, x cannot be positive. The answer is (D).
-
Stuart@KaplanGMAT
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 3225
- Joined: Tue Jan 08, 2008 2:40 pm
- Location: Toronto
- Thanked: 1710 times
- Followed by:614 members
- GMAT Score:800
netigen wrote:ash g wrote:Can you also provide explanation for answer choice [D]. It will be very interesting to understand the explantion. I think it will have to do something with the wording "could be true".
From OG11 DS explanation, what I understand is that
If |x| = +x, then x is zero or positive i.e. x >= 0
If |x| = -x , then x is zero or negative i.e. x <= 0
If both are true, then obviously x=0.
I think answer should be .
|x| is always positive for all x (thats the absolute value concept)
The explanation is given below but I was not able to make it out and hence the posting here:
Example: If x = ±|x| , then which one of the following statements could be true?
I. x = 0
II. x < 0
III. x > 0
(A) None (B) I only (C) III only (D) I and II (E) II and III
Statement I could be true because ±|0| = -(+0)= -(0) = 0 . Statement II could be true because the
right side of the equation is always negative [ ±|x| = –(a positive number) = a negative number].
Now, if one side of an equation is always negative, then the other side must always be negative,
otherwise the opposite sides of the equation would not be equal. Since Statement III is the
opposite of Statement II, it must be false. But let’s show this explicitly: Suppose x were positive.
Then |x| = x, and the equation x = ±|x| becomes x = –x. Dividing both sides of this equation by x
yields 1 = –1. This is contradiction. Hence, x cannot be positive. The answer is (D).
I have to confess, I understand neither the question nor the explanation.
My main question is:
what does the original information mean?
I could mean:
x = + OR - |x|
or it could mean
x = + AND - |x|
If the former is true, then x could be positive or negative and the answer should be all of the above.
If the latter is true, then the only possible value for x is 0 and (b) should be the right answer.
Anyone else as confused as I am?
Stuart Kovinsky | Kaplan GMAT Faculty | Toronto
Kaplan Exclusive: The Official Test Day Experience | Ready to Take a Free Practice Test? | Kaplan/Beat the GMAT Member Discount
BTG100 for $100 off a full course
okee. Thanks for posting the explanation. If the sign ± actually mean multiplying by (1)(-1) i.e by (-1), [as per the explanation provided, this is what they mean]
then the statement x=±|x| can be simplified into:
x = -|x|
or
|x| = -x.
which according to my statement before
=> If |x| = -x , then x is zero or negative i.e. x <= 0
makes I and II correct.
+ in ± is redundant.
I said initially because I took the statement x=±|x| to mean 2 sub statements x = +|x| AND x = -|x|.
Can I ask where did you get this problem from ?
then the statement x=±|x| can be simplified into:
x = -|x|
or
|x| = -x.
which according to my statement before
=> If |x| = -x , then x is zero or negative i.e. x <= 0
makes I and II correct.
+ in ± is redundant.
I said initially because I took the statement x=±|x| to mean 2 sub statements x = +|x| AND x = -|x|.
Can I ask where did you get this problem from ?
-
netigen
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 631
- Joined: Mon Feb 18, 2008 11:57 pm
- Thanked: 29 times
- Followed by:3 members
Nova's GMAT prep course page 76
somehow the author is evaluating equation x = ±|x| becomes x = –x
which sounds like a mistake because in my opinion it should be
equation x = ±|x| becomes x = ±(+x) = ±x
So from my perspective all three cases suffice as a valid answer.
somehow the author is evaluating equation x = ±|x| becomes x = –x
which sounds like a mistake because in my opinion it should be
equation x = ±|x| becomes x = ±(+x) = ±x
So from my perspective all three cases suffice as a valid answer.
