request for profile evaluation

Launched September 22, 2008
This topic has expert replies
Senior | Next Rank: 100 Posts
Posts: 72
Joined: Tue Aug 10, 2010 8:36 pm
Thanked: 2 times

request for profile evaluation

by winner's attitude » Sun Oct 10, 2010 1:49 am
Hi... Thans in advance for evaluating my profile

1) Male , Indian , 30 , Non IT background
2) We have 10+2+3 education system in India ( 10th - 73%, 12th - 80% , was nominated for National Scholarship scheme being a student of top 500 slot out from a pool of 60k students )
4) Undergrads - Bachelors in Business Admin ( we have % evaluation system for graduation in India, i scored 65% in my undergrads , i don't know how business schools evaluate this system, i had been among top 50 students of the university )
5) Executive programme in Business Management ( a part time certificate programme of one year ) from Indian Institute of Management, Calcutta ( IIM C) , IIM is very well know b-school in india. honestly speaking didn't get any value addition from this programme.
6)I was awarded scholarship of 50% waiver in tuition fees by one of the top 10 business schools on the basis of my scores for their entrance exams ( quiet similar on the lines of GMAT ) in the year 2000, because i was among top 50 students of the country.

7) Experience - nine years of experience in Financial Services ( Functionally - Business Development , Retail ) , excellent exposure in terms of leadership , have been leading and managing people for the last seven years now ( jr level manpower in first 4 yrs and mid level manpower for the last 3 yrs ). Have worked with very well known companies of India. Have managed sales teams at state/regional level in the most competitive markets.

Career progression == trainee == officer == sr.officer == asst manager == deputy manager == manager == sr. manager

Now ,here comes the weakness too

1) No international work exposure because my job doesn't demand it all , in IT companies you get to work across globe because the industry demands it wherein my job profile doesn't demand it.. so how would adcom view it ?
2) Nothing to speak as far as EC are concerned... can i develop somehting by the time i apply ? vague question but one of my ex tutors told me if you dont have one... develop one..

Now comes the question Why MBA ?

Wanna get into consulting , so my focus would be sales consulting, marketing and stratagy.

I have been preparing for GMAT and have been consistently scoring 600-640 , but am afraid that this score won't help me in reaching anywhere so am still giving some more time to reach upto 680-700 atleast or 700+.

Now my questions

1) which b-schools do you think are good as per my profile..US as well as non US..
2) I heard US b-schools dont give much importance to international work experience the way europian and other b-schools do , so my chances are better in US b-schools ? how true is this.. because i am more interested in one year MBA rather then going for regular two years MBA
3) Can you comment my profile suitability for INSEAD
4) I am sure that i appear for gmat right now i would score around 650 , so should i appear for gmat or should i make it sure that i reach to a level of 700 , what should be an ideal score for such profile with higher work experience.
5) How would a business school view my plan to shift from industry to consulting after giving such a long time to industry.

I understand a few aspects of my questions are very relative , but would be obliged it you can just give your individual comments on the basis of your experience till date

Thanks very much
Hiren
Source: — Ask Clear Admit |

User avatar
MBA Admissions Consultant
Posts: 900
Joined: Fri Jun 26, 2009 6:49 am
Location: San Francisco, CA
Thanked: 106 times
Followed by:81 members

by Stacey Oyler » Wed Oct 13, 2010 3:55 pm
Hi,

Thanks for your post. Please see my comments below:

1) Male , Indian , 30 , Non IT background
2) We have 10+2+3 education system in India ( 10th - 73%, 12th - 80% , was nominated for National Scholarship scheme being a student of top 500 slot out from a pool of 60k students )
4) Undergrads - Bachelors in Business Admin ( we have % evaluation system for graduation in India, i scored 65% in my undergrads , i don't know how business schools evaluate this system, i had been among top 50 students of the university )
5) Executive programme in Business Management ( a part time certificate programme of one year ) from Indian Institute of Management, Calcutta ( IIM C) , IIM is very well know b-school in india. honestly speaking didn't get any value addition from this programme.
6)I was awarded scholarship of 50% waiver in tuition fees by one of the top 10 business schools on the basis of my scores for their entrance exams ( quiet similar on the lines of GMAT ) in the year 2000, because i was among top 50 students of the country.


Given you have yet to take to your GMAT, it is difficult for me to fully assess this portion of your profile, however, I can tell you that the higher the score the more options you will have. Given the information you've shared, it sounds like you are consistently scoring between 600-640. I strongly encourage you to keep studying, perhaps varying your study methods, and aim to take the test when you consistently scoring 680 or higher. It's not at all uncommon to score anywhere from 10-30 points lower on the actual exam then on a practice test. Please keep this in mind as you continue to prepare.

1) No international work exposure because my job doesn't demand it all , in IT companies you get to work across globe because the industry demands it wherein my job profile doesn't demand it.. so how would adcom view it ?
2) Nothing to speak as far as EC are concerned... can i develop somehting by the time i apply ? vague question but one of my ex tutors told me if you dont have one... develop one..

Your lack of international experience isn't necessarily a deal breaker especially since you seem to have a solid career trajectory to date. Given your extensive work experience, you'll want to be sure to be specific about why now is the right time for you to seek an MBA and a career change into consulting. Adcoms might be curious as to why you didn't decide to do this several years ago.

In regard to your lack of extracurricular activities, I'm not quite sure what your tutor meant by "develop one." If he meant get out and get busy, then yes, I agree! While it might look a bit contrived for you to suddenly start volunteering, you should instead seek out activities that are in line with your personal interest. This will be more compelling to the adcom.

1) which b-schools do you think are good as per my profile..US as well as non US.

This is quite tough to speculate, especially without a GMAT score. I suggest researching top 25 programs.

2) I heard US b-schools dont give much importance to international work experience the way europian and other b-schools do , so my chances are better in US b-schools ? how true is this.. because i am more interested in one year MBA rather then going for regular two years MBA

Many US schools do place an emphasis on "global perspective." This doesn't necessarily mean one needs to have worked internationally, but rather have perhaps worked with others in other countries either through projects or as clients for example. In regard to one year programs, there are many more one year programs offered in Europe then the US.

3) Can you comment my profile suitability for INSEAD


Your potential GMAT score could be a bit low for the average at INSEAD which is 700. INSEAD places a great deal on international exposure and experience, so if you are weak in this area, it may not be the best fit.

4) I am sure that i appear for gmat right now i would score around 650 , so should i appear for gmat or should i make it sure that i reach to a level of 700 , what should be an ideal score for such profile with higher work experience.

If you can hold off and take it when you feel confident in scoring a 700 I would strongly suggest doing so. This will give you a broader range of schools to consider and help boost your overall profile.

5) How would a business school view my plan to shift from industry to consulting after giving such a long time to industry.

See my comments above about your timing. It's up to you to spin it as a good thing.


Regards,

Stacey
Sign up for my MBA admissions course, featuring me and other Clear Admit experts, by visiting: https://www.udemy.com/business-school

Stacey Oyler
Clear Admit, LLC
[email protected]
215.568.2590

Stay Informed with Clear Admit!
Read our Blog for daily MBA admissions tips and updates.
Follow us on Twitter for breaking b-school news.
Download our Publications on MBA programs and admissions strategy.
Visit our MBA Admissions Wiki to read and share application insights.