Is x < 0 ?
1. x^2 > 0
eg 1. x = 2; x^2 = 4
2. x = -2; x^2 = 4
INSUFFICIENT
2. x * |y| is NOT a positive number
Remember: Zero is not considered a positive number either, so we need to count that in.
eg 1. x = -2, |y| = 4 => x*|y| = -8
2. x = 0, |y| = 3 => x*|y| = 0
3. x = 3, |y| = 0 => x*|y| = 0
INSUFFICIENT
Both 1 and 2:
This tells us that x cannot equal zero. However it could still be positive or negative, and satisfy both statements.
INSUFFICIENT.
Pick E.
MGMAT Test 5 - Is x a negative number?
This topic has expert replies
Source: Beat The GMAT — Data Sufficiency |
-
albatross86
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 392
- Joined: Sun May 16, 2010 2:42 am
- Location: Bangalore, India
- Thanked: 116 times
- Followed by:10 members
- GMAT Score:770
-
boazkhan
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 135
- Joined: Tue Oct 13, 2009 10:27 am
- Thanked: 3 times
Hi Albatross,
Thanks for your reply though I am still not very clear...When we take both statements together doesn't it mean that X is not zero because according to Statement 1 we have X^2 > 0 which means X can be positive or negative and since according to Statement 2 the product is NOT positive that only leaves us with a negative value of X?
I DO see how evaluating B alone we have X=0 as the 3rd case but together I am not too sure.
Thanks for your reply though I am still not very clear...When we take both statements together doesn't it mean that X is not zero because according to Statement 1 we have X^2 > 0 which means X can be positive or negative and since according to Statement 2 the product is NOT positive that only leaves us with a negative value of X?
I DO see how evaluating B alone we have X=0 as the 3rd case but together I am not too sure.
GMAT/MBA Expert
-
Rahul@gurome
- GMAT Instructor
- Posts: 1179
- Joined: Sun Apr 11, 2010 9:07 pm
- Location: Milpitas, CA
- Thanked: 447 times
- Followed by:88 members
Statement (1) alone is obviously not sufficient.
Consider just statement (2).
x X lyl is not a positive number implies x X lyl can be zero or negative.
If x X lyl is 0, then either x is zero or y is zero or both are zero.
If x is zero then we know, it is not negative.
If y is zero, x can be negative, zero or positive.
If x X lyl is negative, then since lyl cannot be negative, x has to be negative.
Since we cannot say anything definite about x, (2) alone is not sufficient.
Next combine both the statements and check.
Since x^2 > 0, x is not 0.
Still x X lyl can be zero or negative.
If x X lyl is zero, y has to be zero and x can be negative or positive.
If x X lyl is negative, obviously, x has to be negative.
So on combining what we have is if x X lyl is zero, then x can be positive or negative,
and if x X lyl is negative, then x is negative.
So we cannot say definitely whether x can be negative or not.
Or both the statements together are not sufficient to answer the question.
The correct answer is hence (E).
Consider just statement (2).
x X lyl is not a positive number implies x X lyl can be zero or negative.
If x X lyl is 0, then either x is zero or y is zero or both are zero.
If x is zero then we know, it is not negative.
If y is zero, x can be negative, zero or positive.
If x X lyl is negative, then since lyl cannot be negative, x has to be negative.
Since we cannot say anything definite about x, (2) alone is not sufficient.
Next combine both the statements and check.
Since x^2 > 0, x is not 0.
Still x X lyl can be zero or negative.
If x X lyl is zero, y has to be zero and x can be negative or positive.
If x X lyl is negative, obviously, x has to be negative.
So on combining what we have is if x X lyl is zero, then x can be positive or negative,
and if x X lyl is negative, then x is negative.
So we cannot say definitely whether x can be negative or not.
Or both the statements together are not sufficient to answer the question.
The correct answer is hence (E).
Rahul Lakhani
Quant Expert
Gurome, Inc.
https://www.GuroMe.com
On MBA sabbatical (at ISB) for 2011-12 - will stay active as time permits
1-800-566-4043 (USA)
+91-99201 32411 (India)
Quant Expert
Gurome, Inc.
https://www.GuroMe.com
On MBA sabbatical (at ISB) for 2011-12 - will stay active as time permits
1-800-566-4043 (USA)
+91-99201 32411 (India)
-
albatross86
- Master | Next Rank: 500 Posts
- Posts: 392
- Joined: Sun May 16, 2010 2:42 am
- Location: Bangalore, India
- Thanked: 116 times
- Followed by:10 members
- GMAT Score:770
Yeah I know what you mean, actually when we take both statements together, we do not consider x = 0boazkhan wrote:Hi Albatross,
Thanks for your reply though I am still not very clear...When we take both statements together doesn't it mean that X is not zero because according to Statement 1 we have X^2 > 0 which means X can be positive or negative and since according to Statement 2 the product is NOT positive that only leaves us with a negative value of X?
I DO see how evaluating B alone we have X=0 as the 3rd case but together I am not too sure.
I only said that x could be positive or negative. But remember, |y| could very well be = 0
Thus,
eg 1. x = 2, |Y| = 0 => x*|y| = 0 which is not a positive number.
and x=-2 , |y| = 4 => x*|y| = -2 which is not a positive number.
Thus x could be positive or negative.
~Abhay
Believe those who are seeking the truth. Doubt those who find it. -- Andre Gide
Believe those who are seeking the truth. Doubt those who find it. -- Andre Gide
-
backtoschool11
- Junior | Next Rank: 30 Posts
- Posts: 11
- Joined: Mon May 17, 2010 7:54 am
- Thanked: 2 times
I was having a hard time understanding why C wasn't the answer, but the lightbulb went off when I realized I wasn't thinking about the possibility of Y being zero.
Great problem.
Great problem.
I think that this is a very good question because it seems very easy but has dirty little traps in it. I think that the two main traps are:boazkhan wrote:Is x a negative number?
(1) x^2 is a positive number.
(2) x × |y| is not a positive number.
OA after discussion.
1) "not a positive number"
This means that it restricts just the positive numbers but not zero.
2) considerung that zero is not restricted
X can be either positive or negative because y can also be zero. So the two statements are together not sufficient as the previous posters pointed out.
