B alone is sufficient.
x = 8y + 12 ==> x when divided by y leaves a remainder of 12 so y should be greater than 12.
1) x = 12u
12u = 8y + 12 ==> 3(u-1)/2 = y
Let u = 15 and 17 y = 21 and 24 the GCD are 3 and 12.
Not sufficient.
2) y =12z
x = 8*12Z+ 12
=12(8*z + 1)
12 is factor of x and y . If z and 8*z+1 has a common multiple then GCD is 12 * Common multiple.
For z = 2 to 9 z and 8*z + 1 does not have a common multiple.
So GCD is 12.
B is sufficeint.
Thanks
Raama
Number properties
This topic has expert replies
Source: Beat The GMAT — Data Sufficiency |
-
maihuna
- Legendary Member
- Posts: 1578
- Joined: Sun Dec 28, 2008 1:49 am
- Thanked: 82 times
- Followed by:9 members
- GMAT Score:720
I also encountered this question, but dont agree wit RAAMMMMA explanation though...
I can make this ebn with B:
x = 12(8z+1) where y = 12z
We know 8z+1 will be always odd, 12 need two 2's which will never come..and so B is sufficient...
I can make this ebn with B:
x = 12(8z+1) where y = 12z
We know 8z+1 will be always odd, 12 need two 2's which will never come..and so B is sufficient...

















