BREAKING: Target Test Prep releases Brand New 2026 On Demand GMAT prep course

Redeem

Negation of negation (need expert help)

Expert replies
by voodoo_child » Fri Jun 24, 2011 1:49 pm
Question Stem -
Unlike, wholesale price of lumber, the wholesale price of polymerized plastic has not fallen considerably in the last five years. Thus, although the retail price of wood-based products has not yet decreased, this will soon change, unless the trend in wholesale lumber prices is reversed.

Which of the following .....

I was trying to first analyze the question.

Here's my analysis:
The first sentence is straightforward.


Let's start with the second one: Thus, although the retail price of wood-based products has not yet decreased, this will soon change, unless the trend in wholesale lumber prices is reversed.


The retail price of wood-based products will decrease. (from the second sentence because "this will soon change" negates "not yet decreased". ....(i)
For the second part, "unless the trend in wholesale lumber prices is reversed" => the trend in wholesale lumber prices is not reversed. .......(ii)
Therefore , (i), if (ii) is the structure. Hence, The retail price of wood products will decrease, if the trend in wholesale lumber prices is not reversed. I understood this.

My question is : Do I need to reverse the "The retail price of wood products will decrease, if the trend in wholesale lumber prices is not reversed." Can anyone please help me?

Thanks
Voodoo
Join the discussion
Source: — Critical Reasoning |

by chaitanya.mehrotra » Sat Jun 25, 2011 5:25 am
Voodo,

You should interpret the stem as:

No change in retail prices of wood-->Trend in wholesale lumber prices is reversed
Join the discussion

by Tani » Sat Jun 25, 2011 8:30 am
The first sentence tells us the price of plastic has not decreased, but the price of lumber has.

Second sentence:

Unless the price of lumber starts to increase (i.e.reverse), the price of wood-based products will decrease.

So the argument is saying that lumber prices are dropping and therefore the prices of those things made with lumber will also drop unless the price of lumber starts to increase.
Tani Wolff
Join the discussion